I too have used both for a number of seasons, even tried the hip quiver. Once I made the switch to a two piece I never went back to the detachable. For me it nevermade a noticeable difference in my shooting.

While I do understand the convenience of not havingtheshafts attached to the bow in a tree or in the ground blind (where the arrows can be in the way), there have been times when I have been presented with a second shot [&:], on those rare occasions, one can get off a second arrow, in that critical window of time,with much less movement, andmuch swifter. Also, for me anyway, where the two piece really shines is when one is chasing elk in the mountains. Less noise, lower profile, and quicker to get set up...of course I know those Primos boys would argue with me on that one ....