870 without any hesitation. I sold a 870 super mag when the nova came out. Biggest mistake i have ever made. It constantly jammed shotting 3.5 inch shells and benelli told me i wasn't pumping hard enough to allow the shot round to clear the gun before the second shell was loaded. The following year I bought another 870 and will never buy benelli again. Bottom line, they are cheaper and more reliable guns, service is better through remington, and there are parts/accessories for them everywhere.