You don't like the idea of shooting aluminum because of durability, but you've broken one carbon arrow in one shot with a judo point and have had two others split... Pardon me for saying so, but you're just dripping with contradiction.

Honestly, the lack of durability of aluminum arrows and carbon arrows' better durability are both overly exaggerated myths. A carbon arrow will be more durable than an aluminum arrow of the same weight but the durability gap decreases significantly when you go to the heavier, thicker walled aluminums. Then, aluminum arrows bend and can be restraightened for continued use. Carbon arrows with even a small crack are worthless except as tomato stakes.

Of course, with heavier arrows, then you get into the speed issue. If you want to shoot the fastest arrow possible then you'll have to stay with carbon. But you will need to find a more durable carbon arrow if you're gonna shoot judos. GoldTip Hunter XT's are a far more durable arrow, about the same straightness specs as the CX200's and considerably less expensive.

The Terminator arrows are not lightweight carbons. They are made from carbon and fiberglass, very durable and fairly hefty. If your draw length is more than 29", I think you'd be better off going to the 6075 size, and they are practically the same weight as XX75 2315's.

If it was me and I was wanting to shoot judo points, then I'd go with a heavy aluminum or, maybe, the Terminators. I do not think carbons will stand up to the battering.