Tried the sightmaster for a season but have a fixed pin cobra ascent on new bow. I have no problem picking the correct pin and it is quicker for me. I didn't like the choice of leaving on 20 yards or adjusting sight before shooting. My brain has limited capacity. I agree that it is whatever makes you feel most confident. Mine was a sightmaster 2000 and the new sight has much brighter optics. New ones might be better.