I've always chose a one-piece detachable design that I can remove once I'm at my stand or blind. However, IF I was in a stalking situation, I would prefer a 2-piece attached design. This season I'm using the TR Ridge Hunter and it's a 5 arrow design. I really love the design of the arrow grippers on this quiver. They are a double sized design where larger shafts insert in the top and smaller diameter shafts fit in the bottom, no need to make adjustments. I also love their Snubber Strap, this strap means that you will NEVER have a loose of lost arrow and with the price of quality shafts and expensive b-heads today, that's a nice safety! It's just an awesome design. It's like the Mathews Quiver but to the next level.