Poast vs Vantage? Which is better?
#1
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: New Berlin WI USA
Posts: 85
Poast vs Vantage? Which is better?
I need to purchase a grass selective herbicide for an Alfarack food plot. I know that Vantage is sold by the Whitetail Institute at probably a higher price rate. I have checked at an agronomy place in regard to Poast and know that an oil must be applied with the Poast to insure it sticks to the grasses.
Is there any distinct advantage to either of the products? I just want results, price isn't the option. But if they are comparable, then I would opt for the lesser priced brand.
As always, thanks for your help......
Is there any distinct advantage to either of the products? I just want results, price isn't the option. But if they are comparable, then I would opt for the lesser priced brand.
As always, thanks for your help......
#3
Fork Horn
Join Date: Mar 2004
Posts: 450
RE: Poast vs Vantage? Which is better?
First of all I am an agronomist and there is not much difference between the two chemicals. One has a surfactant and the other doesnt. The best and cheapest surfactant to use is dish soap. A surfactant for lack of better terms makes water wetter. It creates more surface area per water droplet creating a larger area on the leaf for chemical to absorb. Just as commercials say that the soap takes grease out of your way it does the same on plants. Leaf surfaces have a waxy greasy layer that covers leaf surface, using a dish soap will cut the surface tension of the leaf resulting in greater leaf cover. If you have any other herbicide questions go to www.greenbook.com they list all herbicide labels by trade name there. I hope I helped you out a little
#5
RE: Poast vs Vantage? Which is better?
ORIGINAL: texasaggiebowhunter
go to www.greenbook.com they list all herbicide labels by trade name there
go to www.greenbook.com they list all herbicide labels by trade name there
That link doesn't work Tex. Can you corect it. I would like to view that site.
Thanks
#6
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: Byram, MS
Posts: 6
#8
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Western MO
Posts: 321
RE: Poast vs Vantage? Which is better?
WAIT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
God guys...lets be more careful....if you dont know an answer dont give one...Vantage is generic roundup...not close to Poast!! http://www.dowagro.com/ca/prod/vantage.htm
God guys...lets be more careful....if you dont know an answer dont give one...Vantage is generic roundup...not close to Poast!! http://www.dowagro.com/ca/prod/vantage.htm
#9
Typical Buck
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Coffeyville KS USA
Posts: 931
RE: Poast vs Vantage? Which is better?
ditto on the dish soap. i have some generic sethoxydim, and the directions said to use 1 oz of the product and 1 oz of crop oil per gallon. i asked the farm supply place what crop oil was. the guy said to use some dish soap.