RE: Which is bigger?
 

Goliath, by far.

Which is bigger?
 

Goliath:



OR

The Beatty Buck:




Now remember, Just because the Beatty Buck is free roaming and Goliath is raised on a farm, it doesn't matter. They are both HUGE!!!!!

RE: Which is bigger?
 

wow a moving tree, goliath the king! look how old he is. pop pop

RE: Which is bigger?
 

goliath

RE: Which is bigger?
 

Thats two of the ugliest deer I've ever saw! Big yes but darn ugly!

RE: Which is bigger?
 

i would have to say goliath but i would like to see the pictures at about the same distance, but i think that goliath is bigger

RE: Which is bigger?
 

Goliath -- no doubt about it. ;)

RE: Which is bigger?
 

what's the story behind Goliath? I have never seen him before... ????

RE: Which is bigger?
 

Goliath is the King

RE: Which is bigger?
 

I dont care how big goliaths rack is he's uglier than sin. Interesting pics though good post!

RE: Which is bigger?
 

There both dinks,

RE: Which is bigger?
 

Is Goliath a steer deer?

RE: Which is bigger?
 

Goliath is a true monster!!! Is he still alive? I thought someone killed him last year.

RE: Which is bigger?
 

Goliath

RE: Which is bigger?
 

From what I read in the paper, Goliath is a farm deer who was stolen several years ago (Grand Theft Ungulate) and recovered only recently. I think that Goliath has more inches on him. The Beatty was wild, whereas Goliath spends his days showing off his antlers, and impressing the ladies. I just worry the animal's neck is undergoing quite a bit of strain.

RE: Which is bigger?
 

What about this one? It was shot first shotgun season this year. 46 points and a score of 293 3/8. Shot in IL but I dont remember which county.

RE: Which is bigger?
 

Other Side

RE: Which is bigger?
 

Last One

RE: Which is bigger?
 

Hmmmm, man both freaks of nature,lol. but I would say the farm deer has to come off the list and not be counted.

RE: Which is bigger?
 

Mine.

Uncle Matt (in IL)

RE: Which is bigger?
 

goliath looks like a mixed breed between a moose and a reindeer

RE: Which is bigger?
 

The buck with the antlers going every which direction!

RE: Which is bigger?
 

I'm not into the non typicals but I would sure shoot him. Put him out of his misery dragging all that weight around.

RE: Which is bigger?
 

Goliath!