cnhntr

I don't want to start anything with anybody but... why do alot of people shoot all of these tiny bucks?? I'm just wondering.

Idaho hunter 58

For me it was the last day of hunting season. In idaho we don't have things as good as many of you guys. The seasons are short, and not a lot of deer per sq. mile. At least where i hunt. I hold off until the end, last 2 years i have shot does on the last days of the season. I always hold out, but i have never been able to get close to anything larger than a 8 point. But overall i am a meat hunter, so i didn't even hesitate when my large bodies deer walked into the clearing... Big body= lots of meat. Small antlers= no big deal, cherry on top of my sundae! lol

now if only i can get a elk with my bow on the 10th, then i will be a happy camper who has a fridge full of meat!

davidhardegree

cnhntr - I understand your point, however, I haven't seen that many big deer. Dead or alive. I had the opportunity to take this deer, even though he may not seem to be a trophy by most standards, so I took him. My cousin was with me and he has taken deer that were bigger. But, he was just as excited as I was on my first rack. I have heard people say they always look bigger through the scope. Now I know what they mean. Besides, now I can go into the woods knowing that my next buck must be bigger. All-in-all, just a good starting point for me.

PositiveBo

Well, I wish you would have chosen to generate a new thread rather than post this on a grats thread to an excited hunter over his first buck.

However, I can think of many reasons in response to your question. Some people don't have much time or a great area in which to hunt. Some have invested tremendous time and effort attempting to do things right and simply wish to enjoy a bit of a payoff now and then. Some wish to get a buck or two under their belts to calm future nerves at crunchtime when big boy presents an opportunity. Others simply make a 'game time' decision to take a small buck when the circumstances/shot are ideal, and some would simply rather come home with a buck than a doe/fawn. I'm sure there's countless other reasons as well, but the bottom line is they're free to do as they see fit. If it provides them enjoyment, soothes future nerves, puts meat in the freezer, or puts a smile on their face...so be it.

By the way, grats on your bucks guys, proud of you, happy for you, and delighted you're pursuing the sport.