duke1217

i have used both and i have definatly do not like the fresh earth sent. i have just been using the neutralizer and it seems to work alot better. next time u are in the woods dig up some dirt with your hands and smell it then smell the earth scent i know you will smell the difference (smells like chemicals) so if we can smell the difference guess how much the deer will. i do use the acorn scent waffers they do seem to work

LIVE2HUNTNFISH

Duke,
I had the same opinions about the fresh earth scent. I also thought, if it hasn' t rained in a few weeks and the ground is very dry, then that might be the problem. If I had seen deer after a rain, they might not have paid any attention to me.

JimboHunter1

Well hell, after the 35+ inches we' ve gotten here in Maryland over the past two months, the earth scent might just be the way to go! If there' s a tidal wave scent, that would be the best scent ever!

buc617

I' m thinking an earth scent where there is snowfall may not represent the surroundings too well. I have used the Fox urine stuff of different brand names a few times. I have seen more deer with that than most other camo scents. One time a fox came running at me at about a hundred miles an hour! I think those were the plastic wafers. I have rubbed horse crap on my clothes, while hunting near a horse pasture, (make sure it' s not too fresh)! It seems like smoking seems to mask human scent. A few people in my party smoke cigarettes in their stand. They don' t seem to have a problem taking deer. They think since it is farm country, where people burn wood, it kind of fits. Who am I to say? I can' t say I get deer every year.