This Buck has Potential, I think...
 

I looks like he is a 4X5, barely. But, it also looks like he's got a few more buds that might be tines next year.

Im not seeing any potential here.Id take him just to take out his gene pool.

I think he's a youngster who will have taller tines and more points down the road.

He looks like a decent 4-5 1/2 year old....looks like he has hit his peak in my opinion!

I agree.you should take this one out and let the other one grow

That buck is 4.5 - 5.5 years old???? Then he is a complete runt because our 4.5 year old deer are usually 230 pounds and have thick racks.

Maybe my 11 year old will shoot him. :D

Good luck!i bet he would be one happy camper.

shoot him ,don't think he's getting much bigger. Don't see him growing into a monster

I get one buck tag a year. If he's inferior, I wouldn't want to burn my only tag on him. :D

Its ok to use your only tag to take out an inferior buck in your hunting area.it will help to produce better buck in years to come.