Is he a shooter?
 

He appears to be a mature deer. His rack isn't the nicest, but he has a monster body for around here and he would definitely be my biggest buck to date. I'm afraid that I might not see him again if I pass him up, because this is a large piece of property.

i'd put him in the freezer

Having fun hunting him? Then he's a shooter.
It a challenge? Then he's a shooter.
You eat venison ???? Then he's a shooter.
You a trophy guy, then he ain't.
That simple.

He's at least a 3.5 yr old, shooter most anywhere.

Definitions:
Shooter(noun), A deer that fits in your freezer.
Trophy(noun), A deer that fits on your wall and in your freezer.

Whether he's a shooter or not depends on you. I've hunted places (private farms) where we pass them up like that and other places (public hunting areas) where we'd shoot them. If I was hunting in South Georgia, I'd say he's a shooter.

If you would be happy with shooting him then yes. I would shoot him.. thanks for posting

He is definitely a mature deer. So I would take him out at that age in many places he would be considered a cull because of his age but lack of massive horns. On public land he has horns and is mature. So I would shoot him if the chance was presented to me on private or public land.

If he gives me a shot,a shooter he would be. A Buck that size would be twice as big as the only one I have ever shot. A shooter,you bet.

he's old enough to have better horns. Time to make him table fair.

he's a stud, just not a star

I would take him out.

You've named him "Stud". It's a no brainer. He's your shooter. Would be mine as well. Good luck and go get him.

In my area no, yours maybe. Do what your gut tells you

Don't use someone else's standards on what makes him a shooter. If you'd be proud to take him, he's a shooter IMO. That's the only standard that counts.