HuntingNet.com Forums

HuntingNet.com Forums (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/)
-   Whitetail Deer Hunting (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/whitetail-deer-hunting-4/)
-   -   Which would you shoot 1st? 2nd? 3rd? (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/whitetail-deer-hunting/346408-would-you-shoot-1st-2nd-3rd.html)

Bukmastr 07-04-2011 05:52 AM

Which would you shoot 1st? 2nd? 3rd?
 
Ok... Look at the picture. Its gun season, you have 3 buck tags and unbelievably the 3 bucks in the picture all walk into the opening at the same time. What order are you shooting them in? Which one dies 1st? 2nd? and last? and why?


jrbsr 07-04-2011 06:14 AM

If they were all standing in a field close enaugh for a good shot, I would shoot Buck # 2.
I would only shoot one if them, and come back at a later date for another one.
Maybe the next year so they could grow bigger.
JMHO

BarnesX.308 07-04-2011 06:35 AM

How many points are on #2? In certain parts of PA, the buck needs 4 points on a side to be legal :D.

#1 has the most character so I might shoot that one. They're all very nice, though.

Stonewall308 07-04-2011 06:52 AM

In VA we have to shoot a doe before we can shoot a second buck, and we have to shoot a second doe before we can shoot a third buck. So if I haven't shot any does yet, I can only shoot one and I would take #2. It I have two does on my tag already (which I wouldn't because I don't care to take that many does usually), I would take #2, #3, then #1. Then I would have about six hours of work ahead of me trying to drag all three of those monsters out of the remote location where I hunt.

Sheridan 07-04-2011 09:59 AM

I like typical/symmetrical bucks with mass & tine length.

So...........#2 than #3, but I'd be fine if I took #1 anyday !!!

BigDaddy12t 07-04-2011 03:57 PM

I would shoot #1 first for sure, but its a tie on the other ones. I like the mass on #2, but I like thet rack in general on #3.

gonzo1029 07-06-2011 02:46 PM

I would go with #3, then #1, then #2. #3 to me is what a giant whitetail should be. Beautiful 8 point rack with tall tines and some decent mass. #1 has the most character and #2 is just a massive, wide racked buck. Granted wouldn't turn any of them down come season.

halfbakedi420 07-06-2011 03:20 PM

i'd only shoot #2...he, or she, looks to be the oldest of the bunch. the others are very nice too.

Bukmastr 07-06-2011 03:41 PM

score wise highest to lowest would be:
#1 ( 180's NT 15 Point )
#2 ( 160's typ. 9 point )
#3 ( 140's typ. 8 point )

Age wise my best guess would be
#1- 5 y/o
#2- 6 y/o
#3- 4 y/o

Anybody wanna change there mind?

My picks are biased, but would be:

#2
#1
#3

halfbakedi420 07-06-2011 08:25 PM

i would put deer 2 at at least 8 y/o

superstrutter 07-06-2011 09:11 PM

If I shot all three, I would be breaking the law. Just because you have three buck tags, doesn't mean you can take all three in one day. I know here in LA. we get three buck tags, but are only allowed to take one buck per day. If the three came out on me, which by the way would never happen where I hunt, I would probably take deer # 1. If he ran off before I could get a shot, then I'd go for deer # 3.

Bucktail_Bob 07-07-2011 05:28 AM

I judge a deer by loin size. So #2 gets popped.

bb

deerdust 07-08-2011 08:59 PM


The scenario being that you can shoot them, not whether you can in your state. Which one dies 1st? 2nd? and last? and why?


I knew when I saw the pic, that most people would probably be deceived by the rack on #1. It looks smaller of the 3, but by the # of tines would be the largest of the 3. #2 is obviously the most impressive, by his mass and spread, and looks by his age that he may be on the decline. Although only a 9, his mass is going to give you the numbers, as it is good all the way out. # 3 Is nothing to sneeze at. He is a great 8 pt. Good spread, tine length, and fair mass. But still only an 8 pt.

It would be a tough call between #1 and #2 as the 1st shot, but I think I would shoot in this order.

#1- because it is not often you have the opportunity for a 15 pt, even though he may look smaller.
#2- because of his sheer majestic stature. He is a beast!
#3- he is a good 8

BikerRN 07-10-2011 04:45 AM

In order:

2
3
1

Looking at the mounts and trying to guess weight.
I want the heaviest first even if it's only a spike as it will have the most meat.

Biker

TheCReW 07-11-2011 08:25 AM

Just judging by the racks, I would shoot 1 because of the character. But in reality they are all great bucks, and if I could get a good look, I would likely shoot the oldest deer in hopes the younger 2 may get bigger.

OhioBowhunter 07-12-2011 06:55 AM

i'm sorry but i don't see deer #1 at 180"..... but i'd have to say 2, 3, 1 but in ohio you can only shoot one buck, therefore i'd shoot #2 and let the others walk.

excalibur43 07-12-2011 08:04 AM

#2, #3 then #1. If I only had 1 choice it would be #2. He looks more mature, is heavy and more impressive IMO, even though he's only an 8 point.

MZS 07-12-2011 06:20 PM

#2 would be my pick. Then mix the meat 50-50 with some nice beef trimmings at the butcher - I think it might be needed!

tsarge15 07-12-2011 07:12 PM

2, 3, 1. i love mass on a buck. 3 and 1 is pretty much a toss up although it looks like 3 is a little bit taller.

Bukmastr 07-13-2011 05:08 PM

#1

Shed from the year before:

#2



#3

mortalcare 07-16-2011 12:20 AM

#2 first.....largest spread #3 second....he looks to be older and bigger then #1 #1 third.....cuz thats all thats left. but in my opinion #1 wasent a shooter.too young

halfbakedi420 07-16-2011 07:40 AM

unless your 5'2", #2 is a monster..big O' boy there..what ya name him?




Originally Posted by Bukmastr (Post 3823591)
#1

Shed from the year before:

#2



#3


A11en 07-17-2011 01:46 PM

none - all too small

Sheridan 07-17-2011 02:30 PM


Originally Posted by A11en (Post 3824535)
none - all too small


Are you going to put a "LOL" (laugh out loud) after that statement ???

:hail:

Sheridan 07-17-2011 03:04 PM


Originally Posted by A11en (Post 3824535)
none - all too small


Are you going to put a "LOL" (laugh out loud) after that statement ???

:hail:

Bukmastr 07-18-2011 05:38 PM


Originally Posted by halfbakedi420 (Post 3824254)
unless your 5'2", #2 is a monster..big O' boy there..what ya name him?

"The 400 pound Slob"

Here is an article about that buck:

The 400 Pound SLOB: by Dan Infalt


It was a full two hours before dark, when I heard the 1st deer coming through the cattails. Slurp, Slurp, his feet made the unmistakable rhythmic, sound only feet getting pulled out of muck can make. It kept getting closer, till finally a 140 class ten pointer emerged into a creek that separated me from the bedding area. The buck crossed the creek right where I expected, the turned and headed right at me. I was a mere 6 feet of the ground in a natural blind formed near the union of several huge limbs in a gigantic willow tree that sat alone in an otherwise treeless environment, I got nervous, as I looked directly into the eyes of the beast. It felt like he was starring me down even though I new he did not know I was there. Finally at 7 yards from the tree he turned with the trail and quartered away He stopped at 10 yards to work over a primary scrape offering me a perfect shot. As he walked away, I questioned my decision to let him go.

Just a few days earlier I had seen a much larger buck cross the creek on the same trail, and work this same scrape, as a matter of fact I had seen him several times since the summer. I could not put my tag on a lesser buck, until I gave this buck a worthwhile effort. I could still see the ten pointer working over some unlucky dogwood bushes in the distance, when a ripple in the creek caught my eye. The buck had slipped in while all my attention was focused on the 10 pointer. I felt foolish for momentarily loosing my concentration enough to lose the ability to hear this one coming. It only took a glance to recognize the buck that had filled my thoughts and dreams since the 1st day I seen him. His massive 9 point rack was dwarfed by the biggest body I had ever seen. He crossed the creek and turned facing me, my nerves and emotions were going nuts. If it was hard to look the ten pointer in the eyes, this was nearly impossible. I kept focused as the slob buck hit spot 7 yards away where the trail finally turned away from me. He stopped facing me head on, put his head down, smelled the ground, then raised his head starring right at me. I wondered if he was hearing my heavy heart beat, but after a short look he just flicked his tail and followed the trail, When he started working over the same licking branch the earlier ten point had worked, I eased my bow back. The arrow was perfect. The buck jumped, looked around then just fell over with a loud thud, and a little kicking.

The 162" score did not do justice for this monarch. His main beams were nearly 30 inches long, and carried there mass all the way to the blunt tips. His tines had circumferences as big around as most bucks bases. You can't just throw a score onto a buck like that. When my friend and I, finally got the monster out of the swamp and back to camp, we were amazed when it bottomed out my 300 pound weight scale after field dressing. This buck had to be near 400 pounds alive. I have crossed paths with a few unlucky bucks that scored higher, but this would be my best buck, the one that meant the most.

The moral of this story is not just to brag about my favorite buck, Instead, I would like to share the scouting that was involved in getting this buck. First of all, it should be said that I believe a hunter seeking a mature whitetail should spend far more time scouting than hunting.

Scouting for me, never really starts or stops, its kind of always going on. Its funny how your ears tune into anything hunting related or having to do with the where abouts of the next monarch. Any way, after hearing about some great bucks some people had seen in a certain area, and seeing some huge sheds another guy had found, I decided to check out this new property. It started at home, looking over plat books to determine land borders and owners, and viewing aerial photo's to find starter points. I started driving around this particular swamp, looking at the trails and tracks in the snow, and also looking at how the local hunters accessed there hunting spots. I walked the land completely, starting in January and completing in march. I looked for the food sources, buck bedding areas, doe bedding areas, travel funnels, rubs, significant tracks, etc. I learned how the bucks traveled this land. However, even more importantly, I learned how other hunters hunted the land, I found the trees they hunted out of, the permanent stands, there parking spots and travel routes to and from there stands . This was then mapped out, and when I compared the travel and bedding of the bucks to the travel hunting of the hunters, I was then able to find overlooked areas where big bucks could find some peace on this property. As usual, one of the best spots was right next to the road only a few hundred yards from the main parking spot. The bucks were bedding in cattails mixed with small trees and dogwood bushes on the other side of a creek within a stones throw from the road. All the hunters walked down the path a way then some turned off and set up, some went to the middle of the swamp and set up. But nobody, walked along the road and set up near the parking lot. It was one of the few spots these bucks had not felt human invasion. The best part was that if I parked my truck just right, I could see into the staging area, and view the bucks as they staged after leaving there bedding area just before dark. Of course this had to be done covertly. I would make believe I was reading the paper and never wear hunting cloths or have hunting stickers on my truck as I did not want to tip off other hunters to where the bucks are. Occasionally all summer I would glass the bucks seeing all the bucks that came out of the bedding area and how they moved around the staging area. At the same time I was watching other bucks in other areas as back ups. I needed a good wind in order to hunt this spot, and once the season came, it was a waiting and watching game until everything was perfect. By watching deer like this, I had learned that a good wind is not necessarily a wind blowing away from the bedding area. This is because the deer would naturally come out much later, or use a totally different exit when the wind was not in there favor, but with the proper cross wind, that was close to being in there favor, I could slip in and get the job done. Moral of the story. 300 hours scouting 1 hour hunting. There are no magic gizmo's, no pixie dust, no easy way to consistently produce huge bucks. You just have to do the work. You have to do the scouting..

HardwoodHunter 07-18-2011 09:31 PM

#2, outstanding mass on it, #3's length is amazing, but #1's character is crazy...but I think it'd have to go #2, #1, #3. IMO

halfbakedi420 07-19-2011 11:32 AM


Originally Posted by Bukmastr (Post 3824955)
"The 400 pound Slob"

Here is an article about that buck:

mannn 400lbs...wow...absolute giant. be kewl if ya got all them aged by their teef. i am bettin 9 years er more on him. i bet he was a bruit in his day too.

pure havoc 07-19-2011 11:38 AM

none there all to small :D


jk I like #3 very symetrical 8 pt big score if he had a little more mass

timberGHOSTSNIPER 07-19-2011 02:49 PM

I would have to bust off on buck #2!


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 11:04 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.