![]() |
Originally Posted by Siman08/OH
(Post 3713306)
Just wondering, How ethical would it be to shoot this buck? If he was pen raised?
Don't see that, even if he notified the game farm, they would be able to catch it. Then again I guess it would depend on how tame it is, but the simple logistics of trying to find one deer in the woods.... can we say needle in a hay stack? |
Trail cams are unethical and unfair to the deer. Just like baiting.
|
If the buck escaped from a pen during the summer, the antlers would have been in the earlier stages of growth and all the points would have not been developed. Why would a game farm cut the antlers like that, if they cut the antlers when they are shipped they cut the main beam about the brow tine. I think it is just a reflection/glare in the flash caused by the deer being so close to the camera.
|
Timbercruiser is right, you guys are jumping to conclusions. A deer farm wouldn’t cut antlers like that. If you look, they’re sharper now than they would be naturally. When a deer farm cuts antlers they cut them off at the base for safety reasons. I think something’s distorting the photo, though I don’t know what.
|
is it possible thats just how the antlers grew? the brow tines arent cut and it even looks like it has a drop tine that isnt cut
|
Yeah I thought that they wouldn't cut them at a sharp angle like that, but I can't come up with any other reason for a deer's antlers to look like that.
|
That is quite odd, what ever the case ground that dude & you'll have the "rest of the story"! They do appear cut off to me, even the drop tine. Ten to twelve miles would not be out of the question. That may be like me sending my small town son off to big town college, there is "lot's" to look at, and I'm sure he is constantly checking the "wind".:confused0024::confused0024:
|
Originally Posted by isatarak
(Post 3713435)
Trail cams are unethical and unfair to the deer. Just like baiting.
How is this? Trail Camera's don't shoot deer? Even if you get a picture of a big buck on it, you still have to be able to connect with it during legal shooting hours. That is a ridiculous statement.:hit: |
Originally Posted by isatarak
(Post 3713435)
Trail cams are unethical and unfair to the deer. Just like baiting.
Baiting is legal in a lot of states so again as long as your are within the law and hunting by regulation I dont think this is an ethics issue. If you have oaks planted on your property is that unethical? |
Originally Posted by Siman08/OH
(Post 3713306)
Just wondering, How ethical would it be to shoot this buck? If he was pen raised?
If he was pen raised, then his winter foraging and survival skills may be low. So what would be worse, to die of starvation or a gunshot to the heart? I'm not saying he won't do just fine in the wild (assuming he was pen raised), but certainly the odds are against him when competing against the "more experienced" deer. |
| All times are GMT -8. The time now is 09:58 PM. |
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.