Is this the same buck??
 

My brother shot this nice nine point about a mile from where I've been watching/chasing a nice nine point all summer/fall. I was wondering how many of you think this is the same deer. Just so it's clear, I'm ecstatic for my brother, I'm just curious if this is the same buck.

I don't think so. I took my magnifying glass, and looking at the deer in the corn field, it appears he has a real funky/strange looking left antler. Really hard to tell, but I am pretty sure it isn't the same deer.

Really hard to tell but I would say yes.

Based on teh browtines, I would say no. The early pick of the buck looks to have taller tines that point more towards each other. In the kill shot, they look wider. Its a tough call though.

Hate to tell ya but........ same deer.

yeah it's the same deer. the right brow tine is the same, and the G2 tine is curved just like the one in the pic on the right.

Gotta agree with TimerCruiser. NO dice

doesnt look like tha same to me. the main beam on the left sid "looking at the pic" doesnt match up to me

I think it is the same deer purely based on brow tines.