How do you control neighbors dogs??
09-10-2008, 06:33 AM
#82
Fork Horn
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 158
RE: How do you control neighbors dogs??
ORIGINAL: MJR10
Yeah I think I am going to file a complaint that the dogs came after me on my land. Then if I end up having to take the laws into my hands it will already be on record that they attacked meonce....and the next time tehy attacked me I had a gun with me....
Yeah I think I am going to file a complaint that the dogs came after me on my land. Then if I end up having to take the laws into my hands it will already be on record that they attacked meonce....and the next time tehy attacked me I had a gun with me....
09-10-2008, 08:19 AM
#83
Typical Buck
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location:
Posts: 751
RE: How do you control neighbors dogs??
Some of you guys are rediculously ignorant andselfish. Shoot them? Poison them? If killing a deer is THAT important that you have to kill a dog that knows he's doing no wrong, you have way worse issues to deal with. Do it humanely and atleast send them to the pound where they have a chance for adoption from somebody responsible before they die.
09-10-2008, 08:26 AM
#84
Giant Nontypical
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: fort mcmurray alberta canada
Posts: 5,667
RE: How do you control neighbors dogs??
Some of you guys are rediculously ignorant andselfish. Shoot them? Poison them? If killing a deer is THAT important that you have to kill a dog that knows he's doing no wrong, you have way worse issues to deal with. Do it humanely and atleast send them to the pound where they have a chance for adoption from somebody responsible before they die.
They have 20+ dogs that are still breeding each other.
As for catching them and taking them to the pound,are you going to risk getting bitten by a dog that likely hasn't even had it's shots while trying to catch and transport it?
09-10-2008, 09:00 AM
#86
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location:
Posts: 342
RE: How do you control neighbors dogs??
The issue appears to be settled law in Missouri - see court's language below. Furthermore, in the first two cases I found, one dogowner was awarded $4,000in damages and another was awarded $1500.I don't know about you, butthat's enough$$$ for me tothink long and hard before shooting a dog.
In one of the cases,thedog ownerhad five dogs that chased coyotes onto the neighbor's property. The neighbor/farmer/livestock owner shot them...and would up with a judgment against him.
From Mo. courts -
No one has the right to shoot a dog on his property merely for being there when the dog is not threatening imminent danger to the person's property. Mo. Rev. Stat. 273.030
In Missouri dogs are property and no one has a right to kill or harm them except for just cause. Gerhart v. City of St. Louis.[and how often is a courtgoing to find that killing a dog because it is interfering with your hunting is "just cause"?]
Moreover, no one has the right to kill a dog because it is found on his land when threatening no immediate danger to his property. Reed v. Goldneck
In one of the cases,thedog ownerhad five dogs that chased coyotes onto the neighbor's property. The neighbor/farmer/livestock owner shot them...and would up with a judgment against him.
From Mo. courts -
No one has the right to shoot a dog on his property merely for being there when the dog is not threatening imminent danger to the person's property. Mo. Rev. Stat. 273.030
In Missouri dogs are property and no one has a right to kill or harm them except for just cause. Gerhart v. City of St. Louis.[and how often is a courtgoing to find that killing a dog because it is interfering with your hunting is "just cause"?]
Moreover, no one has the right to kill a dog because it is found on his land when threatening no immediate danger to his property. Reed v. Goldneck
09-10-2008, 09:10 AM
#87
Giant Nontypical
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: fort mcmurray alberta canada
Posts: 5,667
RE: How do you control neighbors dogs??
From Mo. courts -
No one has the right to shoot a dog on his property merely for being there when the dog is not threatening imminent danger to the person's property. Mo. Rev. Stat. 273.030
In Missouri dogs are property and no one has a right to kill or harm them except for just cause. Gerhart v. City of St. Louis.[and how often is a courtgoing to find that killing a dog because it is interfering with your hunting is "just cause"?]
Moreover, no one has the right to kill a dog because it is found on his land when threatening no immediate danger to his property. Reed v. Goldneck
No one has the right to shoot a dog on his property merely for being there when the dog is not threatening imminent danger to the person's property. Mo. Rev. Stat. 273.030
In Missouri dogs are property and no one has a right to kill or harm them except for just cause. Gerhart v. City of St. Louis.[and how often is a courtgoing to find that killing a dog because it is interfering with your hunting is "just cause"?]
Moreover, no one has the right to kill a dog because it is found on his land when threatening no immediate danger to his property. Reed v. Goldneck
09-10-2008, 09:20 AM
#88
Boone & Crockett
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Southwest Ohio
Posts: 10,277
RE: How do you control neighbors dogs??
I dont think that most folks here are arguing that one should shoot dogs just for running onto someone's property. This is an instance where it has been established that they are a nuisance and the owners won't do anything about it. Sometimes special circumstances require special measures.
09-10-2008, 09:31 AM
#89
Join Date: Sep 2008
Posts: 9
RE: How do you control neighbors dogs??
ORIGINAL: MJR10
Yeah I think I am going to file a complaint that the dogs came after me on my land. Then if I end up having to take the laws into my hands it will already be on record that they attacked meonce....and the next time tehy attacked me I had a gun with me....
Yeah I think I am going to file a complaint that the dogs came after me on my land. Then if I end up having to take the laws into my hands it will already be on record that they attacked meonce....and the next time tehy attacked me I had a gun with me....
your post, threads, pics have been sent to the Steuben County NY Sheriffs dept. Your posts have intent to commit cruelty to animals. I have saved your pictures onto my hard drive from your trail cam which has your name on them. There is enough information here for you to loose your hunting permit for a very long time. If you think I am joking I am not.
ABAROFSOAP,
You also have put many images of yourself on this forum and the internet for people to see. We know you hunt on Long Island. For you to say you will kill someone's dog and write "just the begining" in blood on his porch is downright disturbing. We do not need anyone like you in the woods with a weapon in your hand. YOUR PROFILE, PICS AND POSTS HAVE BEEN SENT TO THE NASSAU AND SUFFOLK COUNTY SHERIFFS AND LOCAL NYS DEC.