Muzzleloader or Shotgun/Slug gun. Which do u prefer? Why?
#1
Spike
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location:
Posts: 86
Muzzleloader or Shotgun/Slug gun. Which do u prefer? Why?
I am purchasing my first muzzleloader this year for whitetail and I'm curious if any of you prefer a black powder rifle or shotgun/slug gun? Why one over the other? Here in Ohio we have 9 days Gun season (which can be shotgun or muzzleloader) and 4 days of just muzzleloader. There also is a 5 day period which certain areas in the state have open muzzleloader season.
I know some sit in stands and others drive the deer so some situations would be different but if you only had to choose one which would it be?
I know some sit in stands and others drive the deer so some situations would be different but if you only had to choose one which would it be?
#2
RE: Muzzleloader or Shotgun/Slug gun. Which do u prefer? Why?
once you get behind that muzzleloader and just shoot one time you will be hooked trust me. i fell in love with mine and i will use it to drop them deer every time. but here in illinois we can use muzzleloader during the shotgun seasons. yea you get one shot but the are accurate
#3
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Gleason, TN
Posts: 1,327
RE: Muzzleloader or Shotgun/Slug gun. Which do u prefer? Why?
I like hunting with a muzzleloader. The kick on my omega is a lot less than my slug gun. The effective range is close to the same with both. And I just enjoy muzzleloader hunting.
#4
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Ohio, USA
Posts: 189
RE: Muzzleloader or Shotgun/Slug gun. Which do u prefer? Why?
I'm in Ohio too and I much prefer my muzzleloader. That being said, I have a very inexpensive ML that shoots great and is very accurate, but a pain in the rear if it is raining cats and dogs. So if it's regular gun season and anything more than a light rain, I take the shotgun. Otherwise, the ML gets to go with me.
#7
RE: Muzzleloader or Shotgun/Slug gun. Which do u prefer? Why?
I travel from arkansas every year to hunt with my cousin in jefferson and carroll counties in ohio. I use my muzzleloader when i go. My cousin is always trying to get me to use one of his shotguns, but i always decline. I am use to my smokepole not his shotguns. Oh by the way love those big deer running around up there.
#9
RE: Muzzleloader or Shotgun/Slug gun. Which do u prefer? Why?
Muzzleloader, I can't use my shotgun during our ML season, but I can use the ML in both seasons. I don't own a slug gun, and don't really want one since my pump shoots fosters just fine.
#10
RE: Muzzleloader or Shotgun/Slug gun. Which do u prefer? Why?
Unless you plan on cross dressing the shotgun for Bird hunting or Waterfowl hunting,
I would go with the Muzzle loader... Seeing you have a longer season.
Plus it only takes one well placed shot to make a clean kill!
I also have the option here and I most always take my muzzle loader.
It happens to shoot better groups @ 100 yards than my .270, go figure?!!
On top I have a 2X7 Leupold VXII.
It is the first Knight 50 cal. "disc" muzzle loader
I would go with the Muzzle loader... Seeing you have a longer season.
Plus it only takes one well placed shot to make a clean kill!
I also have the option here and I most always take my muzzle loader.
It happens to shoot better groups @ 100 yards than my .270, go figure?!!
On top I have a 2X7 Leupold VXII.
It is the first Knight 50 cal. "disc" muzzle loader