Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

Big boy in the back ground.

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

My opinion at that glance is no. Tines don't look to be long enough. Beauty buck no doubt. My guess and it's obviously just a guess I would say 150's. SHoot him and let's find out. I hope I am wrong. Good Luck.

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

I think the one in front will score better than the one in the back.

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

I disagree but both are very nice bucks.

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

nice bucks either way

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

I rest my case!!! You call this deer hunting... I call it deer shooting... What would all you guys do if you didnt have fields, food plots and bait to hunt over

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

I know if it were me i'd take either one they both look mature and nice mass

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

Technically, I doubt he will be a "Booner" too many deductions. I too believe that front deer would score better. But IMO "nets are for fishing". Ifthey grow it... count it. I have the virtual "twin" that first buck that is 161 3/8" as a 10.
Good luck you should be pleased with either of those boys.:)

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

I guess we'd hunt the timber.:D:D

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

Did you mean boner cause I just got one

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

Read the caption on my website under hunting. "We do not utilize feeders, foods plots, mineral sites, or man made funnels." This picture is taken on the border of public land in Arkansas. The camera is under a licking branch in the corner of a hay field. I value the fair chase aspect of hunting more than most.

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

def. not a " booner "

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

Either one would be a booner in my book. Not much chance of seeing many bucks bigger than that in the area I hunt. I wonder if Mr. Longbeard uses any un-natural hunting items. As he must be a turkey hunter, maybe calls, camo, blinds and maybe a shotgun or bow while hunting turkeys? I gotta figure out what case he is making now.

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

No, he won't go B&C. Great buck nonetheless. Good luck.

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

Too hard to tell from the picture but 2 shooters either way:)

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

I dont think he's 170, but he is a wall hanger for sure.

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

Don't let Boone and Crockett determine a good buck. Either one of those bucks would be great to have on your wall. :)

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

pretty sure the question was " is he a booner? " Personally, unless with a bow, I'd let him walk. To each his own.

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

by looking at the pic he appears to be about 3.5 to 4.5 years old the chest doesnt hang down much but as far as letting him walk well i think i would shoot i just like venison

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

With a typically silly statement like that, who cares what case he's trying making? LB is noted for these outlandish outburst's.[:'(];) Not a Booner, but still a great buck.

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

Tell ya what i'll come harvest both and i will let you know what they score LOL;)

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

I agree with wash...let me come shoot one and I'll let you know...heck I'll even let you in on a picture or two and send ya some meat!

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

not a booner but nice bucks~!

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

If someone is fortunate enough to harvest one of these bucks. I will post pics and a green score. My guess on the bigger of the two is in the mid 160's. The other i think will be high 140" pushing 150".

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

Nice bucks but no B&C.

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

To each his own...but...you'd pass a 160" deer?

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

That's what I was thinking????
Should I be going to NY this year instead of OH?

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

no but he is a nice one

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

those are huge big bucks and I would put them in my Bank of Magnums for sure.

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

the close on is a no, but the one in the background is a bruiser no doubt, he is big now and will get bigger after velvet

RE: Giant Bucks... Is he a Booner?
 

The bigger buck in the background will be high 160's pushing 170 gross, too many deductions though. Lets see him dead and hard horned.