Which buck would u shoot?
 

Which buck would u shoot?
Pic:1

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

pic:2

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

pic 1 for sure cant tell how big deer is in pic 2

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

Definately Pic 1 nice 8pt. and has a nice square body, pic 2 i would let go for another year.

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

I have to say the second one.Theres to many leaves and still to green with no color to be deer season to shoot the first one yet.

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

Pic 1 was taken 10/17/06, bow season was open.

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

Pic one. But knowing me, I'd shoot whoever came out first.

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

I'd go with buck 1, the second one is just covered with a bunch of hair, IMO.

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

Both.

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

same as in the other forum, pic number one would be my choice.. Offers the best shot and seems to be the oldest deer.

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

The deer in Pic1 is def. a shooter in my book. Pic two is too hard to tell, possibly a shooter. Pic 3 needs another year or so.

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

Greg, is that the buck you pm'd me a pic of? Looks like it. He's a STUD of an 8pt.

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

i picked pic one cause there wasnt an option for shooting both, all i gotta say if i was out and saw either one, and the regulations say it was legal at that time, i wouldnt choose, either one is good to me. i dont go for trophy, i hunt for meat and just being out in the wilderness.

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

ditto:)

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

#1 - It's hard to tell but seems to be the bigger buck.

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

I would take 1

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

Yep! That's the one.[&o]

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

I would take either or, and my reasoning would be becauese I think it's the same deer.

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

Buck 1...

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

LOL.....Ditto!!!

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

I would rather shoot pic 1 , nice mass good main frame 8 but i would proubably shoot whichever came first.

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

Nah, I think the throat patch on both deer are different.

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

Pic one, he looks to be a nice one!!!!!!!!!! I really can't tell on pic two! But either one would be fine!

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

Pic one for sure. They almost look to be the same buck.

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

neither

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

both :eek::D

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

I can not see how big the other one is becuase the angle of the picture.

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

#1 looks to be the more mature buck but it is hard to judge from the angle #2 is at

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

Both....! But if I had to pic I'd say 1 w/ the photos provided

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

Pic one. Just can't get a good read on pic 2 although it should be a good deer this year and even better next.

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

NICE!!!!

RE: Which buck would u shoot?
 

im gonna go for the " trick question, same deer i think, BUT im not sure, call me stupid, lol, i'd shoot either one, tho the second deer doesnt look to have a huge body ( tho i cant tell good from the front ) it does seem to have thick horns, i cant see the base, but for them to be that wide that far out i bet the base is thick, or failry thick, def. not skinny lil base