Could This Buck Make Book? (Pic)
 

Northeastern PA 10 pointer.

RE: Could This Buck Make Book? (Pic)
 

great buck! it makes my book....a booner? no.

RE: Could This Buck Make Book? (Pic)
 

Get him measured, that is the only way to know, you can't tell just by looking at it. It is a very nice deer though, I would love to get a buck like that.

RE: Could This Buck Make Book? (Pic)
 

:Dhe'd be on my wall for sure

RE: Could This Buck Make Book? (Pic)
 

Great deer the one hanging beside you in the first picture is no slouch either!

RE: Could This Buck Make Book? (Pic)
 

Congrats! He'd make my book, but will probably miss the B&C book!
170 net, is a lot more deer than most people realize!

RE: Could This Buck Make Book? (Pic)
 

Both of them are brutes... Don't know about any books.

RE: Could This Buck Make Book? (Pic)
 

awesome buck, I'm thinking he is going to come up about 15 inches short, I'm calling him 150-155 class.....................


Regardless he is something to brag about!

congrats

RE: Could This Buck Make Book? (Pic)
 

What is the score to get in P&Y?

RE: Could This Buck Make Book? (Pic)
 

not positive I think 120 or 130

RE: Could This Buck Make Book? (Pic)
 

thats a TON of mass i would guess he will go about 165 " but tape him he might surprise you not a booner though. great buck none the less if he were to have about 8 inch brows no problem.

RE: Could This Buck Make Book? (Pic)
 

Wow great buck. If you don't mind me asking, where abouts do you hunt? I grew up in Pike County, attempt to get down a few weekends during the bow season although it's a little difficult.

RE: Could This Buck Make Book? (Pic)
 

Very nice bucks, but I think the overall tine lengths will come up short. They are uneven and that would pull them down also.

RE: Could This Buck Make Book? (Pic)
 

Is it just me.. or are those pics of 2 different deer?

Lots of mass.. but I don't think he'll hit the 170" mark for B&C... P&Y is 140" if I remember right.. but must have been killed w/ a bow to make P&Y.

RE: Could This Buck Make Book? (Pic)
 

yeah, that second pic looks alot smaller than the first. i know you see spread in the first one and not the second, but it still doesnt look the same.

RE: Could This Buck Make Book? (Pic)
 

P&Y is 125 typical 155 non typical bow only.

Really nice deer.Not a B&C but who cares it's a brute.

RE: Could This Buck Make Book? (Pic)
 

I can't tell for sure if he has a 'G4' on his right side or not. If he does, he will be about 157" typical. If not, about 143".

RE: Could This Buck Make Book? (Pic)
 

Looks like the same deer to me. G2's are good but the rest are short. Brow tines not long as well. (for a B&C I mean ;)or I'm guessing I should say)

Like has been said.....WHO CARES!!!!

Wallhanger for sure!!!!!!!!!! Nice deer.

RE: Could This Buck Make Book? (Pic)
 

Thats definitely a wall hanger

RE: Could This Buck Make Book? (Pic)
 

We hunt Sullivan County.

RE: Could This Buck Make Book? (Pic)
 

AWESOME BUCK!!!! He's not gonna make B&C unfortunately. It sucks I know. But hey he's on the wall and he's a gorgeous deer. I missed P&Y by 1 &3/8 " this year, so I feel your pain. Awesome buck though for sure.

RE: Could This Buck Make Book? (Pic)
 

Good looking buck.

RE: Could This Buck Make Book? (Pic)
 

Thats a really nice back, Wide rack