nny243

When you find deer droppings in a clump, like a horse, does that indicate a buck or is it any old deer who's not eating enough fiber?

DARTanian

well did you pick any of it up and smell it??????did you taste any of it? just kidding<img src=icon_smile_big.gif border=0 align=middle> i don't think that it makes any difference, it probly just had the partial runs at the time of the last dump,or it peed on it just after it pooped, but to tell the truth i don't really know but i want to hear the answer when it comes arround<img src=icon_smile_big.gif border=0 align=middle>

IF IT IS TO BE......
IT IS UP TO ME......

USAFBOUND

Usually it means it's a buck's droppings. I mean sure it could also be a deer that isnt getting enough fiber but I would have to go with it being a bucks droppings. Do you see more piles of droppings that are clumpped like the one you described or do you see both or more single dropping type? If you see more of the clumpped type than MABEY it is that their isnt enough fiber in the area food but if you consistantly see both than I would tend to also think it is a bucks. Good luck and Good Hunting

9th tine

I don't usually go by the dropping's,Other than the fact big deer big poop,Little deer little poop.I have seen some doe's that have left some good size dropping's
I know this probly doesn't help any,Forbuck travel routes I usually look for rub's or scrapes.
If you have doe's there than buck's will be there sometime.

BOB
BE SURE OF YOUR SHOT&WHATS BEHIND YOUR SHOT.,,MAKE A QUICK CLEAN KILL

wvvet

You can't tell the sex of the deer by looking at its droppings....sorry. This is an old wives tale.

Does, as well as bucks, can leave large solid stools or pelleted stools. It all depends on what they have eaten.

mauser06

ive always been told a clump is a buck and pellets are doe..that can bo wrong once in a while....squeeze some out after killing one of each....all the ones i have proved me right....

Tifford

I read an article about this once upon a time but it has been a long time ago and I can't remember where it was from or even if it was a reputable source. Just b/c it was in print doesn't mean it was right either. I think what it said was this.

The number of pellets in the droppings (most of the time) determines if it buck or doe. There are exceptions to the rule the article noted. I'm not sure how they accounted for the various size deer out there or the variety of each species. It would be a nice topic to investigate. I would think that there are too many variables out there. One would have to consider what they are eating to make a fair comparison.

I think the only way to find out the answer to this question would be to have a deer farm where the deer are keep in stalls and each feed a measured amount. Then have a biologist count the pellets each day. My guess would be the bucks do put out more pellets with some of the larger females beating some of the smaller males for pellet count. Sounds like a job for a grad student.

Tifford

Hold Steady

Turd Fergusen

I think the deer was constipated!<img src=icon_smile_big.gif border=0 align=middle><img src=icon_smile_big.gif border=0 align=middle><img src=icon_smile_big.gif border=0 align=middle>

Striper Phil

I think you are all full of Pellets. Pile size is by deer size and thats the poop on that 11 Striper Phil

model722

It depends on what the deer are eating as far as how they crap. This time of year bucks have a different diet, lots of protien. This may be were the old wivestail comes in to play. I've always been told the clumps were bucks.