buckbuster14

Thats a great buck. I wish I could see a 120 class deer.

mnsqueeze

id say that the nicholal buck could get to about 172 (would like to see the spread) but that is what im guessing ., and the swampthing 1st one im saying around 156 5/8 and the 2nd one im goin to say 143., you are right pictures are hard to tell untill you really put a tape to it ., but those are my guessesby the way they are all NICE deer!!!

JagMagMan

Score?????

SwampTHING

Well I really couldnt believe Mnsqueeze gave those measurements. He is the man too have sitting next too you scoring deer in the field! He was off by a total of 4.5" total between the 2 deer!

First buck 10 point with sticker on left g1, 152.5" b&c, its got really good mass throughout.
Second buck, 13 point 142-5/8' b&c, alot of points, but is lacking in mass.

I would pull the trigger on either one,, unfortunately havent had the chance too pull the trigger on anything of that size. I did set my buddies up in the stands that they killed those deer out of.. Theyre first bucks either one of them have ever killed!

muckland

158 & 3/8s

JoeRE

if i got a pic of that buck(in iowa for body size comparison) i would put him at 160 maybe an inch or two more(really depends on spread). im talking gross, the only score i pay attention to. he has brows well over 5 inches long, great beams, only average tine length otherwise. but i might be wrong of course cause velvet is always hard to judge