jcchartboy

I took this NY buck this year, we estimated it was a 2.5 yr old....it was 116lbs dressed.

Arrowmaster

Here in West Central Indiana 1 1/2 yr old 135 to 145, 2 1/2 yr old 145 to 155

Big Guy01

Here in my part of Ontario (farm country) we get some big bucks. Not big antlers just big bodies. 1.5 year oldswill go 140-160, 2.5 will go 160-180 on average, field dressed.

deerslayer223

here in western pa. I'd say the 1.5yr olds ive shot have dressed out around 125 with the 2.5yr olds dressing out around 150-160 on average.

jcchartboy

Slayer,

Is that "best guess" or have you actually weighed a bunch?

I live in southern NY and we have good sized deer and I don't think ours "on average" go that big.

Rob/PA Bowyer

Actually I think that's a unfair poll, your asking between a 1.5 and a 2.5 year old and they'd fall into two different answers.

BTBowhunter

I agree. a 1 1/2 and a 2 1/2 would be a notch apart in the answer choices.