illegal?
 

I hate to mention and it's a good thing my step brother is not computer literate enough to be on the site, but anyways, every year my dad gets landowner tags for my brother and I, and he usually gets some for him too, but for the last 5 years he did not hunt and had these tags. My brother and I never used them becauseI thought it wasillegal. But my dad remarried and she had a step son. He got our landowner tags as usual and all of a sudden Bernie (my step brother) wanted to go hunting. Mydad gave Bernie his tags. He went hunting and got a really nice 9 point. The mass was huge! My dad telechecked it. They got it mounted also.Bernie was going to submit itto the Missouri Big Bucks, butfelt bad (or probably worried if he would get caught), because it wasn't under his name, and didn't wanna put it under mydad's name because he didn't shoot it. At that time, I think you could only have 1 antlered deer.He used my dad's tag and didn't buy any others to get another buck. I don't know if it was illegal, but he really regrets doing it. Now,he lives in NC trying to get a bigger deer, but he says the deerare tiny there. After reading the possible indiana buck story...I guess this kinda relates. I won't say Bernie's name, healready hates me enough.

RE: illegal?
 

Cest' La Vie

RE: illegal?
 

My guess is that it is probably not legal, andmaybe heshould feel a little guilty:(

RE: illegal?
 

It's all about the name on the tag.

RE: illegal?
 

He felt so bad that year that he wanted to turn himself in. If he had done that, would he had gotten in trouble? The deer is at our house, he lives in NC going to college. Could they take away the deer?

RE: illegal?
 

whats that mean?

RE: illegal?
 

If it was illegal, and I'm pretty sure that it was (illegal here in Tx.)Yes, he would be in truoble, and yes, they could confiscate the deer!
Also, its probably a really good thing that he didn't enter it in any contests! A couple of years back here in Texas, some idiot entered a buck in the Texas Big Game Awards contest. He got fined, and got serious jail time too! Those contest entry forms are legal documents! Filing an illegal one is usually a felony!

RE: illegal?
 

wow, I guess it's a good thing he didn't. What do we do about this?

RE: illegal?
 

What do you want to do about it? Do what you can live with. If you can't live with it don't do it whatever it is. Ugh, did that make sense?

RE: illegal?
 

I can't live with it because in all reality, we havea "poached" deer on the wall...my step-brother don't see it that way, but he feels guilty and sad because he can't enter it in any contests.

RE: illegal?
 

whats done is done............dont enter it in any contests and youll be fine andno one will find out only if you tell them.

RE: illegal?
 

Eat the deer and enjoy it....

dd

RE: illegal?
 

lol, sorry, we already ate it...but it's head is on the wall....

RE: illegal?
 

It wouldn't bother me considering that in WI you can shoot somebody's elses buck. You have to be in visual contact or yelling distance. So if I did it I would be following the law in WI.

RE: illegal?
 

i'd feel the same way that you feel......

RE: illegal?
 

Party hunting is perfectly legal in Ontario, as long asa tag holder is in the woods with you and you have a way of contacting them immediately after a kill.
Of course we only get one tag each so if party hunting wasn't legal my season would have been over in October.

RE: illegal?
 

Geez, move out. If its only bothering you wait til you move out and forget about it.

RE: illegal?
 

I'm more concerned for my dad than anything else. He gave him the tags. Does is matter that it was on our own property?

RE: illegal?
 

Sorry if I annoy you guys for stupid questions...:(

RE: illegal?
 

You don't spend much time here if you think your questions are stupid !!

RE: illegal?
 

[8D]shoot, it's 3:37am, and I'm still on this site :D

RE: illegal?
 

Take him off the wall and shoot him again them tag him correctly.