HuntingNet.com Forums

HuntingNet.com Forums (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/)
-   Whitetail Deer Hunting (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/whitetail-deer-hunting-4/)
-   -   would a dead deer float? (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/whitetail-deer-hunting/120375-would-dead-deer-float.html)

flyby 11-09-2005 10:10 AM

would a dead deer float?
 
hi..shot a deer monday am. it jumped down a steep bank to rocks at the rivers edge. after waiting 1/2 hour we went to get it. blood at where i hit it...blood all over the rocks at the rivers edge...but no deer. we searched the 20 acre woods for rest of day all day yesterday. no blood or tracks coming out of water on other side of river ( about 30 ft wide) but very deep.
would the deer sink if it died on the rocks and slipped into the water?
thanks for any ideas ...anyone witha similar experience? am going to see if it has floated up tommorow...
frustrated.

JOHNE 11-09-2005 02:09 PM

RE: would a dead deer float?
 
Yes they do, I used to hunt strip mine land and because the ground was so impassable we would float the deer across the lake to the small boat landings. We could back to truck up to the deer and lift it in alot easier.

m.t.hands 11-09-2005 03:00 PM

RE: would a dead deer float?
 
i have walked a creek before feeling for deer a friend had shot, found sticks limbs and whatever, but we also found the deer, not sure when they sink and when they float but i can assure you they will sink for a time, i have seen it twice....

BTW welcome to the forums, flyby and johne

TXhighrack 11-09-2005 04:14 PM

RE: would a dead deer float?
 
Deer will float. We find atleast one each year floating inthestock tanks on the ranch. We've also shot deer and had them run into the water, they have always floated.

krub6b 11-09-2005 07:02 PM

RE: would a dead deer float?
 
Remember that things float only in they are lighter than th water they would displace. Things that would float on a deer are fat and it's lungs(if they don't have a hole and blood in them), and things that won't: everything else.

So, was it a fat deer? not big bodied, fat! Are it's lungs intact or in small pieces in his chest surrounded by blood? A good way to figure that up is was the blood on the bank bright red? If so your deer was quickly dieing and probably died while swimming and then sank because it's lungs had to air in them to help keep him afloat.

He may float to the top tomorrow or the day after if he hasn't become waterlogged due to the bullet hole. If he does, do not puncture his skin!!! The only reason he came to the top is because the decay of his flesh is producing gas causing him to float. I'd advise just checking him in and then if you want the antlers to cut them off and dispose of the carcass.

mauser06 11-09-2005 08:03 PM

RE: would a dead deer float?
 
i really dont see how they can float when hit with a bullet......i put some holes in deer.....atleast an inch hole in and out usually....when things fill with water they sink.....i know fat and such floats.....but theres a good chance the deer would fill with water....how deep is it?? able to look in it easily?? good luck

jcchartboy 11-09-2005 08:15 PM

RE: would a dead deer float?
 
I can't answer whether a freshly killed deer will float. Just as some humans would and some would not, I believe that would depend on the specific deer.

I can tell that every deer will float short after death for a period of time. This is due to the microbial action within its digestive system. Even after the deer is dead microbes still break down the food in its stomach.A by-product of this process is of course various gases. These gases will build in the stomach creating a balloning effect that will cause the deer to float.

121553 11-09-2005 08:31 PM

RE: would a dead deer float?
 
Theres not too much water around here in the winter that ain't frozen, but I've never had a problem dragging them across ice or snow. ;)

Bobby

Hiawatha 11-10-2005 08:08 AM

RE: would a dead deer float?
 
I would venture to say yes. A few years back i was on a blood trail of a bull elk i had arrowed when the trail led down to the river where we found the bull floating in the middle. We gave him close to 2 hours b4 we tracked him so he couldn't have been in there for that long of a period. I do alot of beaver hunting here in the spring and usually the beavers will float in the water when dead for some period of time. I have had beavers sink and came back the next day to find that the rose to the surface. I know beavers are dif from a deer but it might be a suggestion to keep checking the body of water for a few days. Meat won't be any good by that time but you would have an explanation as to what happened.

buck knife 11-10-2005 08:22 AM

RE: would a dead deer float?
 
I have found deer that ran into a river down river because of the current and they usually are floating or caught up on some logs or other debris.

flyby 11-10-2005 08:24 AM

RE: would a dead deer float?
 
thanks for all of your great input!
could not go back up yesterday or today..but am going up to see if he did indeed float up tommorrow am.
yes, the blood was bright red and we found some lung tissue at the hit sight...so i hope he will be there.
we could'nt see the bottom as its really deep (10-12 ft)...i hate the waste of meat and of a prime buck(8 points) but maybe i can at least claim the rack. guess we should have tried to drag the river with something...but that would have been hard to rig up and come up with at the time.
thanks again and i will keep you all posted on the results of this saga...

callemin 11-10-2005 04:43 PM

RE: would a dead deer float?
 
As far as I know all deer will float due to the fact that a deers' hair is hollow. It will work as a flotation device. Good luck with the deer.

uncle matt 11-10-2005 06:42 PM

RE: would a dead deer float?
 
They certainly can swim. Maybe he scooted over to the other side? Maybe look over there for a blood trail?

tj_cubin 11-10-2005 07:15 PM

RE: would a dead deer float?
 
matt, he said there was no blood or tracks on the other side

i have heard that humans will float for a short period and then sink, then they will bloat because of the decay and micro organisms and whatnot, and they will float back up. So... both??

flyby 11-11-2005 12:47 PM

RE: would a dead deer float?
 
hi !
well , he was there. bloated up and floating about 200yds downstream.
one antler broken right off the other half craked off.
shot right through.just behind shoulder blade..so we think he did a header right off the cliff onto the rocks and bounced right into the river . dead.
too bad. he was my first buck too. but i feel better as the mystery is solved and my shot was bang on. under "normal" circumstances he would have gone 50 yards and died.
thansk for you help!
ps. right through both lungs so i imagine he sank very quickly.

kshunter 11-11-2005 01:03 PM

RE: would a dead deer float?
 
They float. I hunt near a large river, and have had them die in the water on more than one occaison. They'll stay near the top of the water.

manitou210 11-11-2005 07:33 PM

RE: would a dead deer float?
 
I live in Canada and the Deer hair this time of year the winter hair is like a staw hollow in the middle, for extra warmth for winter, and they float, no question

krub6b 11-11-2005 09:48 PM

RE: would a dead deer float?
 
Hateto hear the rack wasn't salvagable, but good to know it was a good hit.

Tree climber 11-12-2005 04:24 AM

RE: would a dead deer float?
 
where I hunt there are two rivers running through,we have taken many , many deer that went into the water.9 out of 10 will sink just below the surface.if you look close it looks like a small brown bowl at the top of the water.most times if you don't get to it in a few min. then it will go down.shot through the lungs with a rifle or shot with a shot gun with buckshot, it will sink almost immediently. that 1 out 0f 10 will go down like a rock. I have saw this many times. we have even had a guy take his scuba gear and find them for us 10 to 15 yards from where they went into the water.
I guess it all depends on how the deer was hit.

CrazyBuB 11-12-2005 05:49 AM

RE: would a dead deer float?
 
happened locally here a few years back.. but it was a pond, so no running water or current.. took 24 hours but the buck surfaced.. btw it had 27in inside spread... monster


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 04:32 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.