Graves

SBEII, its its 3.5" better waterfowlin gun, i have one and abosltuly love it

NCZ09

The SBE II is an awesome waterfowl gun. Get one you won't be disappointed.

Sagittarius

I rather have the SBE II but prefer the Beretta XTrema 2 to both.

SecondChance

I own 2 Super X2's, 1 Browning Gold, and Browning BPS. All in 12 ga and in 3-1/2". That being said, I use SBE II at work and have shot over 5K rounds through them and have NEVER had a problem with them. I just happened onto the others before really shooting the SBE. If I were you, I would buy the SBE in 3-1/2 and if the need ever arises that you want/need 3-1/2" fodder, you will have it at hand and not be wanting it. My .02 cents.

coastal1

Problem solved...Get a Beretta! You will love it.

DrHouse

If both were presented to you free of charge which one would you take? That should be the answer to which one you buy.

I'd choose the SBE II personally. Even though you don't shoot 3.5's right now, it's easier to have a gun that can accept them if that time ever arises, then to have a gun that can't.

Sheridan

+ 1

"I rather have the SBE II but prefer the Beretta XTrema 2 to both."

NCZ09

Hey lundinbridge, you started this thread last March. What the heck did you get and have you put it to work this season?

Lundinbridge

i went with the vinci. havent used it yet this season but looking forward to a good season with it.