need help on new waterfowl gun
#1
Spike
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2006
Posts: 90
need help on new waterfowl gun
hi guys ive been looking for a new 3 1/2 semi auto shotgun that will cycle all loads and not wanting to go over 800 dollars i almost ordered a supermag waterfowl edition today glad i didnt after reading some of the feed back on here and i already have a 935 any help will be appreciated thanx
#2
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Jun 2008
Posts: 1,526
RE: need help on new waterfowl gun
Browning Gold or a Winchester Super X3. Practically the same gun. Both are soft shooting, easy to clean, and very reliable. You should be able to get the Gold for under $800 fairly easily, but you may have to shop around for the X3.
#6
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Jun 2008
Posts: 1,526
RE: need help on new waterfowl gun
Browning is no longer making the Gold. Instead they are focusing on the Silver, and the X3 (Winchester).
Here are the major differences:
The 12 gauge Silver does not have the speed load feature or a magazine cutoff switch. Most of the Golds have a magazine cutoff switch but, not all of them. While the Silver, and SX3 models don't have a cutoff switch they all can cut off the rounds in the magazine by pushing up slightly on the carrier while pulling back on the bolt. This blocks the rounds in the magazine, ejects the chambered round, and locks the bolt back/open. The Silvers don't come with shims for their stocks but can use the Gold Clacssic/FLD's.
Also the Gold will be slightly thinner in the forearm than the Silver, but the X3 will be even slimmer.
Here are the major differences:
The 12 gauge Silver does not have the speed load feature or a magazine cutoff switch. Most of the Golds have a magazine cutoff switch but, not all of them. While the Silver, and SX3 models don't have a cutoff switch they all can cut off the rounds in the magazine by pushing up slightly on the carrier while pulling back on the bolt. This blocks the rounds in the magazine, ejects the chambered round, and locks the bolt back/open. The Silvers don't come with shims for their stocks but can use the Gold Clacssic/FLD's.
Also the Gold will be slightly thinner in the forearm than the Silver, but the X3 will be even slimmer.
#7
Join Date: Apr 2009
Posts: 9
RE: need help on new waterfowl gun
Question...why 3.5 inch...probably dont really need that...3 is usually almot alwaysplenty good...Brownings have always been a good guns....
perhaps shop for a "slightly used" gun rather than new...??
Stoger 2000, bought one for my daughter its been fine gun and economical...no problems for us...generic Beneli, have heard everyone I know thats had a X3 except one got rid of it....various reasons sited....
Baretta Extrema is softest 3.5,about as good as it gets, SBE are ok, lighter, but more recoil felt....both are expensive new, but maybe used for a little over your 800.00 especially maybe a Extrema I vs. II.....
For used guns and leads....
Check www.gunsamerica.com
perhaps shop for a "slightly used" gun rather than new...??
Stoger 2000, bought one for my daughter its been fine gun and economical...no problems for us...generic Beneli, have heard everyone I know thats had a X3 except one got rid of it....various reasons sited....
Baretta Extrema is softest 3.5,about as good as it gets, SBE are ok, lighter, but more recoil felt....both are expensive new, but maybe used for a little over your 800.00 especially maybe a Extrema I vs. II.....
For used guns and leads....
Check www.gunsamerica.com
#8
RE: need help on new waterfowl gun
Ill admit I do not hunt WF near as much as Id like to, and no where near as much as most of you. My gun sees about 5-10 duck hunts a year, that said, I love my SX3, its a sexy and very durable gun , very manageable when shooting 3.5 #1 loads, love the duratouch stock and I think its got some kind of teflon finish. I paid about 1000 for it 2 years ago but Ive seen them for less now. Funny though it shoots light 7/8 oz target loads and 3.5 " loads w/ out a hicup but doesnt seem to like anything in between.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Always wanted to be on a Hunting Waterfowl Show? Saskatchewan,Canada Waterfowl and also offers Bears
huntingtime1975
Big Game Hunting
1
08-19-2006 11:31 PM