Help me choose - REM 870 or Benelli Nova, Super Nova
 

Remington 870
Benelli Nova
Benelli Super Nova



I believe its down to these three. You say one that shoots a good pattern, but I don't think they let me go shoot one before I buy.

I also an considering a pistol grip for the Nova or a thumb hole Shurshot for the 870, any thoughts on these?

New to Turkey Hunting. Never used a pump before, always autos.

I hunt in Indiana. Like a gun that I can maneuver well, a tactical feel. I want a trouble free gun that can take being dirty and still function. I dont hang out at gun shops and don't even know where to find a gun smith, so I don't want trouble.

Benelli hands down = Remington 870 was a very good shotgun - I own several - but the new Remingtons contain stamped metal parts and are not the quality they once had.

The Benelli's - far superior andless trouble and far more bang for your hard earned buck!

JW

+ 1
Benelli Super Nova

Thanks for the replies

Is there a good turkey model in the NOVA that gives me a pistol grip?

What do you think about pistol grip for turkey hunting?

What are the differences between a NOVA and a SUPER NOVA and is it worth the money?

Thanks

I have recently bought a Benelli Nova in Max-4 camo, and I love it. I think that for turkey hunting, the Nova would be a better choice because of its rugged reliability. Don't get me wrong, I have used plenty of 870's and they are one of my favorite guns, However the Nova seems better fitted for the turkey woods. I'm not aware that Benelli makes a pistol grip version of their Benelli, but they do offer a tactical option. It really doesn't matter much if you get the Nova or the SuperNova, Both are guns that can be dragged through the mud and still fire reliably.

Benelli Supernova sonds good to me, doesnt really matter which you use aslong as you shoot em dead!!!!

The Novas amongst the last of my choices, and the 870s amongst the first. Mainly for feel. We're already talking pump action shotguns from 2 good makers, what else do you want in "rugged reliability?" Go feel 'em up and make your choice from there is what I'd do.

Remington 870 SM max gobbler

I wonder what the price difference is between a benelli and a Remington???

Oh and were is the benelli made at;)

I have used both. A 1970's vintage Mod. 870, 12 ga. was about my favorite shot gun for years. It was stolen. A few years ago I won a nice gift certificate and used part of it it to buy a Nova "Turkey Gun". No problems. Killed plenty of Toms with it. As far as grip style, I figure that is a personal preference. I am right handed and have had to make several "left handed" shots on Toms. With a "standard" grip, that is a simple transition for me. Not sure how that would work with a pistol opr thumb-hole grip.

Nova will kick the a$$ off of the Remington but I own both ;)

My first turkey gun as a Nova. Great gun. I would take it for sure over the 870.

I just recently traded in my Super Nova with pistol grip for a SBEII that I could duck hunt with. It shot really well with a Jellyhead choke and the new Hevi-shot Magnum Blend.

I used an 870 for years and still own it. The biggest difference was weight. I have owned that thing about 20 years. It is by far one of the most rugged guns you could ever own.

If it's a dedicated turkey gun you are looking for I would get the 'Nelli with the pistol grip.

I shoot the nova and am very happy with it. That said, the 870 is also a great choice.

Your opinion Adrian. In that price range, you can't beat the 870. For sure the Benelli is a great gun, but we're talking about the Nova. Not saying it's a bad gun, but to say it will kick the 870's a$$ is a little overboard. As someone said, you can put the 870 trough anything and it will not let you down. I have shot both and the 870 kicks the a$$ off of the Novas:s4:. Of course this is my opinion. BTW, I own two 870's. My main turkey slayer is the 870 SPS-T thumbhole 12 ga.

I like Benellis, but an 870 is a damn sure good shotgun too.

870 vs. Nova
 

I own several 870's along with a Nova, I love them both. The 870's time tested and has a great reputation for excellence, the Nova is relatively new compared to the 870 but definitely excels in poor weather conditions. The Italians are definitely doing something right with their guns because the Nova is absolutely amazing. The Nova is quite a bit thicker in the receiver and stock, but is light and swings great. The 870's light, tough, and reliable. Both are amazing turkey guns, and are both around the same price. Depending on which model of 870 your looking at they can be upwards of $500. I am not aware that the Nova is available with a pistol grip, which adds to the long list of accessories not available to equip this gun with. My advice would be to go to your local gun dealer and handle both guns, see which one fits and swings the best for you.