8pt do I shoot? (pic)
 

This guy is thick and I have pics of him for 3 years so I think he is 4.5 he has not gained much other than mass.he has had about the same rack for the 3 years I have seen him. He was a 6pt until this year.

RE: 8pt do I shoot? (pic)
 

Kill him, then eat him.:)

RE: 8pt do I shoot? (pic)
 

That's totally up to you Moose!:)If you don't, someone else will!:D

RE: 8pt do I shoot? (pic)
 

It all depends on your personal hunting situation. I wouldn't, but I don't have to worry much about anyone else shooting him. If you do, then you might want to consider it.

RE: 8pt do I shoot? (pic)
 

If you have been seeing him for that long he may get a little better. But if he is pushing 5 years he will be on the downhill before long. I would imagine he would be at his potential by now.

RE: 8pt do I shoot? (pic)
 

I would kill him if he is no bigger than that at 4 years old

RE: 8pt do I shoot? (pic)
 

That deer doesn't look to be 4.5 years old. He's to skinny. If anything he is alot younger or way older. Looking at his head and the his shoulder blades he looks old. But his legs are really long looking like a young deer. His face and that skinbetween his armpits looks like he's old. He may be on his way down.

RE: 8pt do I shoot? (pic)
 

I'd shoot him!!!

RE: 8pt do I shoot? (pic)
 

I would not, but that is just me.

RE: 8pt do I shoot? (pic)
 

i would give hive till 6 1/2 that is when they have their best rack.

RE: 8pt do I shoot? (pic)
 

well it could be the tree behind it but it looks to me like it has a 9th point,why don't you shoot it and tell me

RE: 8pt do I shoot? (pic)
 

If you don't have to worry about someone else taking this buck then it's all up to you. You can let him go for another year and see what happens. Me personally I would take this buck. I don't see the potential for much growth.