RE: Is this the same buck??
 

Yup, second and third definelely appear to be the same. The first one I do not believe is the same deer.

RE: Is this the same buck??
 

sorry, ididnt read the captions the first time, but i would say YES

RE: Is this the same buck??
 

First deer is definitely not the same as the second and third, first is an eight point. Second and third look like the same buck lookin at the brow tines. But the first is a different buck than the other two pictures.