Same Deer or Not?
 

My father and I can't agree on this one so I thought I would ask everyone here for some outside opinions. Here are the pics of the 11 pointer I got this year. http://outdoors.webshots.com/album/555965896tSqgStThenattached is a picture we got off our camera a couple months ago. We only got this one picture of this guy. He just never came back to give us a better look. My dad says that this is the same buck that I shot. I am still not convinced that it is the same deer. To me the G2's and G3's look too close inlength to be the same deer. Maybe I just want to think we have another nice buck out there that will grow up to be nice and even bigger next year or maybe my dad is right. Let me know what you think.

RE: Same Deer or Not?
 

A little hard to tell from the angle of the trail cam pic, but I think your deer looks a little larger to me. The tines look taller too.

RE: Same Deer or Not?
 

i think hes the same but its really hard to tell, no way to really tell for sure until next year or if you still have your camera out.

RE: Same Deer or Not?
 

I think it is the same deer.
Set the horns up in the backyard at the same angle and take a picture for comparison

RE: Same Deer or Not?
 

definetly not the same deer. The deer you killed has a big sticker off the left G2. Save the picture to your desktop, and zoom in on the picture of the live deer. No sticker on his left G2. Definetly not the same buck!

RE: Same Deer or Not?
 

I do not think it is the same deer

RE: Same Deer or Not?
 

nope yours is bigger

RE: Same Deer or Not?
 

Seems like the same deer!

RE: Same Deer or Not?
 

its definately a different buck

RE: Same Deer or Not?
 

Its hard to tell but to me they look dang close. It would be nice if they arent though. Thats a nice buck you shot wish i could have shot one that big

RE: Same Deer or Not?
 

I'd say different deer. too many different differences (kicker pt, mass, tine length etc) that you can't allot to different angles. Now if this was from the previous year... Maybe.

RE: Same Deer or Not?
 

i would say it is the same one.

RE: Same Deer or Not?
 

i think its obviously the same one

RE: Same Deer or Not?
 

It's hard to tell. I'd say its the same one, but we have pictures of buck with alot of similarities like these two have so, it could be the little brother to the one you shot. Either way, that's a damn nice deer you shot.

RE: Same Deer or Not?
 

Hard to say.....but what kind of trail cam????

RE: Same Deer or Not?
 

i think its the same deer.

RE: Same Deer or Not?
 

They are very similar. Beyond that it is a guessing game. I hope your luck continues next year.

RE: Same Deer or Not?
 

i think they're different... your buck looks bigger. Your bucks tines are longer and more spread out... and i agree with the comment about the sticker point too. It would help if you could get a picture of the antlers at the same angle as the picture.....

RE: Same Deer or Not?
 

different deer your deer is much bigger

RE: Same Deer or Not?
 

I say they are different deer, it appears that your buck has longer tines and it also appears that the one in the pic has a wider spread than yours. Its hard to tell and I guess the only way you will know is if you get that bruiser on cam again this year.

RE: Same Deer or Not?
 

no cause if u look at your deer the g2 on the right side is smaller then the g3 in the pic it looks like the g2 is larger then the g3

RE: Same Deer or Not?
 

idk and yours looks more massive anyway who cares no matter what thats a trophy deer that you got there