A Dozen Shots With The .50 TC/GM Renegade
12-23-2018, 04:55 PM
#16
Boone & Crockett
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: River Ridge, LA (Suburb of New Orleans)
Posts: 10,917
Ever since I declared them to be so BPS. DO NOT question the Semisane. 
(SIDE NOTE: I was one of the few forum members who opposed breaking out a separate Traditional forum from the Black Powder Forum, reasoning that most members would be reading the posts in both forums anyway.)
(SIDE NOTE: I was one of the few forum members who opposed breaking out a separate Traditional forum from the Black Powder Forum, reasoning that most members would be reading the posts in both forums anyway.)
Last edited by Semisane; 12-23-2018 at 05:35 PM. Reason: To add side note.
12-24-2018, 05:26 AM
#18
Boone & Crockett
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: River Ridge, LA (Suburb of New Orleans)
Posts: 10,917
Aw come on BPS, don't get so hung up on this title thing. 
I was shooting GOEX black powder out of a side lock percussion gun with a scope and using a sabotted bullet. I kinda` figured a sidehammer with black powder fit the Traditional forum best.
Just for fun, consider this. We have a Black Powder Forum with a Traditional Muzzleloading sub-forum. So where do you post if you're shooting an inline muzzleloader using Blackhorn 209? Your rifle doesn't fit in the "Traditional Muzzleloading" forum and your powder, which in no way resembles black powder, doesn't fit in the "Black Powder" forum.
So deciding where to place a post can be a coin flip. Does a scope on a side hammer make it non-traditional? Certainly there's documentation of telescopic sights being used in the mid-1800's. Is a modern scope a no-no, but a replica of an early brass tube sight OK? Would a paper patched bullet fit in the Traditional Forum? If so, is a bullet in a sabot closely related to a paper patched bullet? Perhaps as closely related as Blackhorn is to black powder? DAMMIT! Now I have a headache.
.
I was shooting GOEX black powder out of a side lock percussion gun with a scope and using a sabotted bullet. I kinda` figured a sidehammer with black powder fit the Traditional forum best.
Just for fun, consider this. We have a Black Powder Forum with a Traditional Muzzleloading sub-forum. So where do you post if you're shooting an inline muzzleloader using Blackhorn 209? Your rifle doesn't fit in the "Traditional Muzzleloading" forum and your powder, which in no way resembles black powder, doesn't fit in the "Black Powder" forum.
So deciding where to place a post can be a coin flip. Does a scope on a side hammer make it non-traditional? Certainly there's documentation of telescopic sights being used in the mid-1800's. Is a modern scope a no-no, but a replica of an early brass tube sight OK? Would a paper patched bullet fit in the Traditional Forum? If so, is a bullet in a sabot closely related to a paper patched bullet? Perhaps as closely related as Blackhorn is to black powder? DAMMIT! Now I have a headache.
.
Last edited by Semisane; 12-24-2018 at 11:44 AM.
12-24-2018, 07:19 PM
#19
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Penns Woods
Posts: 1,628
How about this? I'll dissolve my membership to this site so guys like you can have your way. Then you can also request that the traditional forum be dissolved so you won't have to read two forums that are related but still different. I'm not sure why they called the original forum "Black Powder" I questioned that in the past and never got a straight answer. I got sick of the arguments that constantly arose between those who prefer modern style ML firearms vs those of us who prefer traditional. I own scoped muzzleloading rifles and shoot them on occasion but they're not my "go to". If I sit down for a shooting session or hunt with one and want to talk about it, I'd post it in the "Black Powder" forum, not the "Traditional" forum. You can have it your way if you'd like, just say the word.
BPS
BPS
12-24-2018, 08:17 PM
#20
Super Moderator
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Wisconsin
Posts: 7,408
There are posts all the time within the Black Powder forum that would have been better suited in some other forum.
You boys also posted "OFF TOPIC" items which treated the BP forums as more of your own public posting ground.
Many of us let that slide.
I see a Traditional firearm with a few Modern tweaks.
Nothing more nothing less. It's not worth arguing over guys.
Santa is still watching us know.
JW
You boys also posted "OFF TOPIC" items which treated the BP forums as more of your own public posting ground.
Many of us let that slide.
I see a Traditional firearm with a few Modern tweaks.
Nothing more nothing less. It's not worth arguing over guys.
Santa is still watching us know.
JW
