HuntingNet.com Forums

HuntingNet.com Forums (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/)
-   Traditional Archery (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/traditional-archery-19/)
-   -   Crossbow debate (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/traditional-archery/281182-crossbow-debate.html)

ICALL2MUCH 01-03-2009 06:55 PM

Crossbow debate
 
Everyone,

I have not heard anyone mention crossbows on here, in quite sometime. Maybe it is because it is a trad. bowhunting forum? :D

What are your thoughts on them? Agree with their use? Just tolerate them? Love them? It is mostly the old school crowd that doesn't respect them? This debate has always fascinated me, and I'd love to hear your thoughts.

***REASON FOR EDITING*** HNI Rule #10: "10. Linking - Links to produtcs and personal pages will be tolerated. You may not link to any direct competitor of HuntingNet.com or link to just advertise a product or service. We reserve the right to delete any link for any reason


bigcountry 01-03-2009 08:18 PM

RE: Crossbow debate
 
Come on man, don't bring that crap in on this page.

there is a crossbow section. Take it there.

ICALL2MUCH 01-03-2009 08:52 PM

RE: Crossbow debate
 
big,

No crap intended, at all. Just looking for input and different perspectives. I've never got a trad. gear persons input on this. I assume it is con, but I'd like to hear why. Who knows, we might learn something!

Schultzy 01-03-2009 08:56 PM

RE: Crossbow debate
 
Some don't like them and some do like them. I for one don't care for them. There not "bow" enough to me to be considered a bow. Each to there own though.

LBR 01-03-2009 08:59 PM

RE: Crossbow debate
 
There's been a lively discussion or two on this board. I'll see if I can find one.

Chad

ICALL2MUCH 01-03-2009 09:08 PM

RE: Crossbow debate
 


ORIGINAL: Schultzy

Some don't like them and some do like them. I for one don't care for them. There not "bow" enough to me to be considered a bow. Each to there own though.
I hear you Steve. I am all for them, but they are not a bow. At all. It needs another name.

bigcountry 01-03-2009 09:40 PM

RE: Crossbow debate
 

ORIGINAL: ICALL2MUCH

big,

No crap intended, at all. Just looking for input and different perspectives. I've never got a trad. gear persons input on this. I assume it is con, but I'd like to hear why. Who knows, we might learn something!
You mean to tell me, your not smart enough to do a search on the multiple dozens of crossbow debate threads in the bowhunting forum???

You have posted this crap on 3 forums so far. Why? Nothing ever good comes of it.

907Alaska 01-03-2009 09:55 PM

RE: Crossbow debate
 

ORIGINAL: bigcountry


ORIGINAL: ICALL2MUCH

big,

No crap intended, at all. Just looking for input and different perspectives. I've never got a trad. gear persons input on this. I assume it is con, but I'd like to hear why. Who knows, we might learn something!
You mean to tell me, your not smart enough to do a search on the multiple dozens of crossbow debate threads in the bowhunting forum???

You have posted this crap on 3 forums so far. Why? Nothing ever good comes of it.
Very true!

JimPic 01-03-2009 10:07 PM

RE: Crossbow debate
 


907Alaska 01-03-2009 10:17 PM

RE: Crossbow debate
 
Hummm 3 forums...
Maybe try a name change: IPOST2MUCH
:eek:


ICALL2MUCH 01-03-2009 10:18 PM

RE: Crossbow debate
 


ORIGINAL: bigcountry


ORIGINAL: ICALL2MUCH

big,

No crap intended, at all. Just looking for input and different perspectives. I've never got a trad. gear persons input on this. I assume it is con, but I'd like to hear why. Who knows, we might learn something!
You mean to tell me, your not smart enough to do a search on the multiple dozens of crossbow debate threads in the bowhunting forum???

You have posted this crap on 3 forums so far. Why? Nothing ever good comes of it.
Looking for different perspectives. I've never heard a trad gear persons perspective on crossbows. I could suspect things, but I'd rather hear it from the horses mouth. That is how we learn. Open-minded people.

Different people visit different Forums. I'm sure you know that, 16000 posts in.

You're a pretty cozy fella. :D

bigcountry 01-04-2009 06:17 AM

RE: Crossbow debate
 

ORIGINAL: ICALL2MUCH

Looking for different perspectives. I've never heard a trad gear persons perspective on crossbows. I could suspect things, but I'd rather hear it from the horses mouth. That is how we learn. Open-minded people.

Different people visit different Forums. I'm sure you know that, 16000 posts in.

You're a pretty cozy fella. :D
So what do you plan on learning? What good is going to come from this new found knowledge you will have?

Sure different people visit different forums. But there is a reason why there are different forums for different subjects. i wouldn't have a problem if you had a trad question. But you don't.

ICALL2MUCH 01-04-2009 07:46 AM

RE: Crossbow debate
 


ORIGINAL: bigcountry


ORIGINAL: ICALL2MUCH

Looking for different perspectives. I've never heard a trad gear persons perspective on crossbows. I could suspect things, but I'd rather hear it from the horses mouth. That is how we learn. Open-minded people.

Different people visit different Forums. I'm sure you know that, 16000 posts in.

You're a pretty cozy fella. :D
So what do you plan on learning? What good is going to come from this new found knowledge you will have?

Sure different people visit different forums. But there is a reason why there are different forums for different subjects. i wouldn't have a problem if you had a trad question. But you don't.

No trad question, but I'd like to hear trad views.

I plan on learning some trad. views on crossbows. I would assume that most are not for them. Why? Are any of you for them? Indifferent?

Chris W. 01-04-2009 12:30 PM

RE: Crossbow debate
 
I believe crossbows don'tbelong inbow/archery season.They just don't fit my idea of what constitutes a bow.

ICALL2MUCH 01-04-2009 12:39 PM

RE: Crossbow debate
 


ORIGINAL: Chris W.

I believe crossbows don't belong in bow/archery season. They just don't fit my idea of what constitutes a bow.

I would agree with that. Stick and string? Sure. But not a bow.

While I am certainly not against people using them, the term "crossbow" isn't the right term, IMO.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 05:30 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.