HuntingNet.com Forums

HuntingNet.com Forums (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/)
-   Reloading (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/reloading-15/)
-   -   Nosler makes the Partition a bonded bullet (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/reloading/65104-nosler-makes-partition-bonded-bullet.html)

oldelkhunter 07-02-2004 01:00 PM

Nosler makes the Partition a bonded bullet
 
Why have they not done this? I am absolutely content the way these bullets work, but it seems that a lot of people look down on them because they don't have 99.9% weight retention .:D They should just make these bullets for those individuals.

bigbulls 07-02-2004 05:42 PM

RE: Nosler makes the Partition a bonded bullet
 
Why? There is already the Swift A-Frame.

charlie brown 07-02-2004 05:47 PM

RE: Nosler makes the Partition a bonded bullet
 
I agree with bigbulls. If they make the Partition Bullet a bonded core bullet, then they will cost just the same as the A-Frame does and act no differently when they hit an animal. Plus, they already make the Partition Gold, which is just as good if not better than a bonded core bullet.

Vapodog 07-02-2004 06:47 PM

RE: Nosler makes the Partition a bonded bullet
 
Further I suspect Sweift will sue if Nosler bonds their bullet.....The Swift A-Frame is essentially the Nosler Partician bonded up front.....they marketed it first and Nosler needs to pay them Royalties to use their patient.....assuming it's patented.

BTW I've had excellent success with the Swift A-Frames.

pharaoh2 07-03-2004 07:49 AM

RE: Nosler makes the Partition a bonded bullet
 
I'm a little bitter with Nosler right now anyways. I called them about a month back asking why they would not make a .311 dia partition, and well the response I got was not favorable in my books. On the other hand, I called Hornady last week. I was curious on the whole bonded core hoopla, and wanted to know the manufacturing process. The tech I spoke to took the time to answer all my questions, and was polite and pleasant, even to a stupid guy like me. I know who's bullets I'll be buying in the future.

eldeguello 07-03-2004 08:45 AM

RE: Nosler makes the Partition a bonded bullet
 

ORIGINAL: oldelkhunter

Why have they not done this? I am absolutely content the way these bullets work, but it seems that a lot of people look down on them because they don't have 99.9% weight retention .:D They should just make these bullets for those individuals.
Well, because of the way the Partition bullet is designed to work! It is DESIGNED for violent, rapid, explosive expansion of the front core (depending on how fast it is going when it hits), followed by deep penetration of the rear portion. The partition bullet will expand reliably even at long ranges of 500+ yards, after the bullet has lost a lot of velocity, yet it holds together right off the muzzle, even at magnum velocities. IF Nosler bonded the core for great weight retention, they'd lose the violent expansion/long-range reliability they now have, and the resulting bullet would not be as good as the ones they are now making. If you want bonded, shoot the Accubonds. They have a higher B.C. as well as a bonded core.

eldeguello 07-03-2004 08:50 AM

RE: Nosler makes the Partition a bonded bullet
 

ORIGINAL: pharaoh2 I'm a little bitter with Nosler right now anyways. I called them about a month back asking why they would not make a .311 dia partition, and well the response I got was not favorable in my books. On the other hand, I called Hornady last week. I was curious on the whole bonded core hoopla, and wanted to know the manufacturing process. The tech I spoke to took the time to answer all my questions, and was polite and pleasant, even to a stupid guy like me. I know who's bullets I'll be buying in the future.

What did they tell you? (Other than the fact that the demand for a .311 NPJ would not justify the cost of producing them??) I have had some pretty good results with 200-grain .308" Nosler Partition bullets in both .303 British and 7.65 Argentine rifles.

DM 07-03-2004 12:49 PM

RE: Nosler makes the Partition a bonded bullet
 
You guys sound like all there is to it, is to "bond the core". WRONG!!!! To make a bonded bullet is no big deal!! To made a bonded bullet that works right, you need a totally different jacket material and you need to learn how to do the bonding process RIGHT!!! How do i know this??? Well, i use to mfg. and sell them, and i've tested them and others more than i can count, BEFORE getting the process right.

BTW, Swift was far from the first to make bullets this way, i did it, and so did others.

Drilling Man


oldelkhunter 07-03-2004 02:09 PM

RE: Nosler makes the Partition a bonded bullet
 
The Partition has better BC then the A frame and is lower priced

oldelkhunter 07-03-2004 02:09 PM

RE: Nosler makes the Partition a bonded bullet
 
Ok based on your argument then why is the Accubond made with the same jacket material as the partition?

oldelkhunter 07-03-2004 02:12 PM

RE: Nosler makes the Partition a bonded bullet
 
Why is the partition gold as good as a bonded bullet ?...It's just a partiton with a metal cup in the rear partition to retain the lead and the partition is moved up a little and that "little" counts as more retained weight.

oldelkhunter 07-03-2004 02:13 PM

RE: Nosler makes the Partition a bonded bullet
 
I am perfectly content with the current partition design... the point of my post was many people are not even considering it a premium bullet anymore since it doesn't retain x amount of weight after it penetrates an animal...

oldelkhunter 07-03-2004 02:14 PM

RE: Nosler makes the Partition a bonded bullet
 
Nosler partition was around long before the Swift A frame and Bitteroot bullets and others have had bonded bullets out for many years prior to Swift.

charlie brown 07-03-2004 03:12 PM

RE: Nosler makes the Partition a bonded bullet
 

Why is the partition gold as good as a bonded bullet ?...It's just a partiton with a metal cup in the rear partition to retain the lead and the partition is moved up a little and that "little" counts as more retained weight.
The reason the Partition Gold is as good as a bonded bullet is the fact that the steel core allows the bullet to penetrate practically anything that it encounters. Bonded bullets are designed to do the same, penetrate no matter what they hit, and still retain bullet weight. The Partition Gold will do that with no problem, and even a good bonded bullet will have hard time staying together after hitting a heavy bone at high velocities.


I am perfectly content with the current partition design... the point of my post was many people are not even considering it a premium bullet anymore since it doesn't retain x amount of weight after it penetrates an animal...
Another point why Nosler has not made the Partition a bonded bullet is because when it was designed, few big game hunting calibers pushed a bullet fast enough to cause it to blow up when it hit something solid. The Partition still works for these calibers quite well. Move into the magnum and ultra magnum class and it is a whole new ball game. That is why it seems that people are not considering using the Partition because a lot of people are on the velocity high. Talk to a lot of people who shoot .270's and .30-06 and a bonded core bullet is really not necessary to achieve plenty of penetration because the velocities are kept low enough.


The Partition has better BC then the A frame and is lower priced
The reason the partition has a higher BC, is because it is simply a longer bullet per weight. This only comes into account when taking extremely long shots (400 yds +). Inside that, a person will not be able to reasonably tell the difference between a bullet with a BC of .390 vs 490 unless he has a target grade rifle and can hold at exactly the same place on a distant animal every time. Most hunting rifles can't shoot a 3" group at 400 yds anyway and that is about what the difference is between the two. If Nosler were to start bonding the cores on the Partition Bullet (and they obviously have the technology to do it), more time and money would have to be spent to make the same bullet as the A-Frame, therefore raising the cost of each individual bullet on the market.

To prove this point, I just did a little research. I plugged four popular hunting bullets into a balistic calculator.
I used the Sierra Gameking, the Speer Grand Slam, the Nosler Partition and the Swift A-Frame as examples with balistic coeficients of .404, .393, .410, and .367 for the A-Frame. I currently have a load with the gamekings in my Savage 110 that will shoot 165 grain at 2640 FPS. This is at 5000 feet elevation, zero of 200 yds.

here are the results for 100 yd intervals out to 500 yds to line of sight.

Gamekings: 2.1" @ 100yds, then 0 at 200, -8.9" at 300, -25.8, and finally -51.9 @ 500yds.
Speer: 2.2, 0, -9.0, -26.0, -52.5 respectively
Nosler: 2.2, 0, -8.9, -25.6, -51.6"
Swift: 2.2, 0, -9.2, -26.7, and finnaly -54.2 @ 500 yds.

That is a total difference of 2.6" at 500 yds!! the difference in energy figures was within 100 ftlbs!!

I don't know of ANYONE that can be accurate to within 2.6" at 500 yds so no normal person would even notice the difference. I think a lot of people put way too much thought into BC, when it really has no affect on where the bullet will hit in the field.

DM 07-03-2004 04:19 PM

RE: Nosler makes the Partition a bonded bullet
 

Ok based on your argument then why is the Accubond made with the same jacket material as the partition?
Are you aiming that at me????

If so, there are unlimited ways to design and make a bullet. I have no idea what Nosler had in mine with there design, but i can tell you, if the core is bonded into a guilding metal jacket, it will not be as good as a copper designed jacket. It's just too briddle for that.

That doesn't mean it won't work in some cases, but a poster accused Nosler of copying Swift, and i'm saying that just isn't so, "IF" they are each useing a different metal for the jacket material!!!!

This isn't an "arument", it's a FACT!!!

When i mfg'd bonded bullets, i had my jacket material spl. made for me, just like the big boys do so today!!! It's the only way to make the best bullets possible!!

Drilling Man


oldelkhunter 07-04-2004 07:12 AM

RE: Nosler makes the Partition a bonded bullet
 
DM, point I was trying to make is the accubond and the intrabond for that matter do not have copper jackets like a Swift Scirroco or the Aframe.. That is it . I always thought copper would be better for a bonded bullet but evidently a few manufacturers Remington,Nosler and Hornady think differently.

oldelkhunter 07-04-2004 07:20 AM

RE: Nosler makes the Partition a bonded bullet
 
Charlie brown, the basic construction of the PG is identical to the Partiton except the partition is moved slightly forward and there is a steel cap over the lead core in the rear of the bullet. I have used both bullets and I can tell you the PG did not shoot as well as a regular partition. I am basing it on 30 caliber 180's and 7mm 160 grain bullets.


[quote][/Another point why Nosler has not made the Partition a bonded bullet is because when it was designed, few big game hunting calibers pushed a bullet fast enough to cause it to blow up when it hit something solid. The Partition still works for these calibers quite well. Move into the magnum and ultra magnum class and it is a whole new ball game. That is why it seems that people are not considering using the Partition because a lot of people are on the velocity high. Talk to a lot of people who shoot .270's and .30-06 and a bonded core bullet is really not necessary to achieve plenty of penetration because the velocities are kept low enoughquote]

I sort of agree on this with you this. These super velocity magnums kind of change things a bit. That said Lazzeroni introduced his hyper velocity calibers with a Nosler partition bullet and no it was not a PG. In fact he mentioned he didn't like the PG. He evidently now markets a variation of the Barnes triple shock called a Lazerhead.

DM 07-04-2004 07:37 PM

RE: Nosler makes the Partition a bonded bullet
 

I always thought copper would be better for a bonded bullet but evidently a few manufacturers Remington,Nosler and Hornady think differently.
In my opinion, they are useing the jacket material that is easy for them to get, cheaper, and also easier to get accuracy out of! AND, still be able to capitalize on the name "bonded".

It doesn't mean there bullets will be junk, it just means they won't be as good as they "could be". Useing copper, would "really" make them look like they was copying some one else too! It really all depends on what velocity spread you are wanting the bullet to work at too.

It's all about makeing a dime, don't ya know!!!!

Drilling Man



All times are GMT -8. The time now is 11:14 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.