new to reloading which brass
05-21-2006, 08:34 AM
#2
Typical Buck
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Indiana county, Pa
Posts: 681
RE: new to reloading which brass
scott, ive been reloading for quite a while and i usually get remington or winchester brass. these two usually hold up better than the off brands. federal brass is good too. if you want the best get norma but you will pay more for it. good luck with your reloading and please be careful.
05-21-2006, 05:02 PM
#3
Guest
Posts: n/a
RE: new to reloading which brass
Scott, I usually stick with remington or winchester. Usually because of availability and I get once fired free sometimes from ranges. I like federal but it only last maybe 3 fires before primer pocket becomes loose, but its more consistent and softer than the rest. Norma or Lapura are probably the best but you pay for it. I heard the Nosler brass is A1 but you pay even more.
There is some fine brass out there I like Starline I like for straightwall.
There is some fine brass out there I like Starline I like for straightwall.
05-21-2006, 08:16 PM
#4
Join Date: Feb 2006
Posts: 493
RE: new to reloading which brass
Lapua seems to be better than Norma and is cheeper, compared to Rem and Win the price of Lapua is worth every penny. To me the whole purpose of reloading is to improve over factory ammo, so why use crappy brass!!! Hornady claimes to have top quality brass but it doesn't help when they don't have the calibers I need. Nosler may have some good brass but I haven't tried it yet. The thing that catches my attention most is how someone will pay $40-$60 for a box of 20 factory cartriges and then skimp on component brass. Just weigh some of them and you'll see the difference!! I know that Black Hills uses Winchester brass in their match ammo but I suspect it's a better variety than we buy for home use, like the difference between match bullets and plinking bullets.
05-21-2006, 08:35 PM
#5
Guest
Posts: n/a
RE: new to reloading which brass
why buy that expensive brass when its not needed? If your getting subMOA accuracy, its a moot point, unless your one of those folks that "well its more expensive so its better".
Let me tell ya, theres alot more than buying expensive stuff in making straight ammo. Only experience will show that.
Let me tell ya, theres alot more than buying expensive stuff in making straight ammo. Only experience will show that.
05-21-2006, 10:03 PM
#6
Giant Nontypical
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: a van down by the river
Posts: 8,939
RE: new to reloading which brass
why buy that expensive brass when its not needed?
[ul][*]$40 for Lapua[*]$64 for Norma[*]$45 for Nosler[/ul]
The same brass in Winchester or Remington costs me $12. I still get sub-MOA groups when I do my part. For hunting, trying to tighten groups another .05" is trivial. And when I'm hunting, I lose brass, especially when trying to make a quick follow up shot or shoot multiple targets. For what I do, the only thing buying more expensive brass would do for me is lighten my wallet.
05-21-2006, 11:38 PM
#8
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location:
Posts: 2,555
RE: new to reloading which brass
[blockquote]quote:
why buy that expensive brass when its not needed?[/blockquote]
My thoughts, too. For my .223, 100 brass costs about:
[ul][*]$40 for Lapua[*]$64 for Norma[*]$45 for Nosler[/ul]
The same brass in Winchester or Remington costs me $12. I still get sub-MOA groups when I do my part. For hunting, trying to tighten groups another .05" is trivial. And when I'm hunting, I lose brass, especially when trying to make a quick follow up shot or shoot multiple targets. For what I do, the only thing buying more expensive brass would do for me is lighten my wallet.
why buy that expensive brass when its not needed?[/blockquote]
My thoughts, too. For my .223, 100 brass costs about:
[ul][*]$40 for Lapua[*]$64 for Norma[*]$45 for Nosler[/ul]
The same brass in Winchester or Remington costs me $12. I still get sub-MOA groups when I do my part. For hunting, trying to tighten groups another .05" is trivial. And when I'm hunting, I lose brass, especially when trying to make a quick follow up shot or shoot multiple targets. For what I do, the only thing buying more expensive brass would do for me is lighten my wallet.
05-23-2006, 08:40 AM
#10
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Olive Branch MS USA
Posts: 1,032
RE: new to reloading which brass
The objective of my reloading at this point in time is quality, not quantity. I don't reload enough any more towhere the cost of premium brass is an impediment. I like Lapua best and havebecome very fond of the new Nosler brass also. These brands have been very consistent in terms of wall thickness, weight, etc... I've also hadgood luck with Norma,though now that I don't have the .300 Wby I'll probably only use it for the 7.65mm Mauser.
The most expensive brass I've used is RWS and while it wasvery consistent and of good quality overall, I never liked it much. Itwas more difficult to work with because it was so thick and the primer pockets were tighterthan a pair ofSpeedos on a Sumo wrestler. I've still got some, but I really don't have any desire to ever use it again.
I still like Winchester anduse it for my son's .243.It has always produced good results. However, I never took a liking to Remington. It wastoo inconsistent and out of any particular batch there were always too many pieces thathad to be culled.I haven't usedany in several years now.
The most expensive brass I've used is RWS and while it wasvery consistent and of good quality overall, I never liked it much. Itwas more difficult to work with because it was so thick and the primer pockets were tighterthan a pair ofSpeedos on a Sumo wrestler. I've still got some, but I really don't have any desire to ever use it again.
I still like Winchester anduse it for my son's .243.It has always produced good results. However, I never took a liking to Remington. It wastoo inconsistent and out of any particular batch there were always too many pieces thathad to be culled.I haven't usedany in several years now.