|
Giant NY buck: 205" typical
This buck was killed by Dave Edwards in Cortland County, NY on the final weekend of the regular firearms season. The deer reportedly scores 205 gross / 185 net. Looks like it'll be this year's biggest typical in NY. Congrats to Dave on tagging one heck of a NY buck!!!
    |
ehh, I must've let 3 or 4 just like that walk this year!
:jaw: No kidding, though-that is impressive; on the last weekend no less!! |
Magnificent!!!
|
wow, that is a true monster
|
Beautiful. Too bad regarding the deductions tho (if the green scores were accurate).
|
WOW,, Nice Looks like a brother
Hey WNY Bowhunter the big buck you listed on 11-30-10 looks like it could be a brother to this one...
I hunted Steuben County this year also , We do see some nice bucks but not quite in that caliber.... He must be all bone ... Nice buck... |
He'd have been a dandy next year....:rolleye0011:.....:).....
|
A very nice buck! congradulations!
|
Originally Posted by Ridge Runner
(Post 3745495)
awesome buck no doubt, but it has more than 20" in deducts, scored as a typical its scored as a 10 pt mainframe. and the whole right side is weak, accompanied by a broken right mainbeam. still an incredible buckRR
|
Originally Posted by Ridge Runner
(Post 3745743)
Any point that doesn't come off the top dead center of the mainbeam and doesn't have a matching point on the other side is a deduction.any thing abnormal over 1" is a deduction, look at the difference in lengths of the points on the right side compared to the same points on the left antler, thats all deductions if its over an inch.Right mainbeam though may not be broken it is somewhat shorter than the left, that also is a deduction.2nd point on the right horn is odd, thats also a deductionRR
Are you familiar with the hunter and the deer other than on this thread? I justed posted the numbers that I was given. |
20" deductions, right side weak, G2's off. Blah, Blah, Blah. Net scoring is all for symetrics, and evenness. I say its crap. A Buck is what it is, and thats alot of darn nice bone on his head. I would careless if its symetrical thats a darn nice giant that would make any hunter very proud. Its a great representation of what NY is capable of, and even better it came from a different county than the well known big buck ones.
|
Sweet Buck!! That must have looked huge coming thru the woods. Now if I can just figure out where the Top Trail Tower is.... Congrats Dave Edwards!!
|
wow...great deer
|
Originally Posted by Ridge Runner
(Post 3746049)
no I'm not but the G2 as you call it, is out of place, if it were scored as a G2, the left side points would all have serious deductions due to differences in length, as you would be measureing the actual G2 on the right, and comparing it to the actual G3 on the left, and so on on down the line. is that not right? Was the green score done by a B&C measureer? if so can you post the score sheet?I'm tellin ya its a great buck, a buck of a lifetime even, I just see more than 20" of deductions is all.RR
Did you see this bruiser that I posted? http://www.huntingnet.com/forum/nort...er-ground.html |
:violin:Awesome buck, wish they would grow them that large here in Northern NY!
|
hey no negatives here, Its a Awsome Buck, and i dont think many would pas him up if that monster walked through where they were, Great harvest and congrats to the harvester!!
|
I would pass him up, too many deductions and a broken tip.
Yeah right, that buck is too die for. I keep hoping that "next year will be the year...." and that I'll get a Booner, and I've been hoping that for 21 years now. |
Nets are for fish :D
That thing is a hammer....congrats to him! |
I'm not too keen on the coloration of the left side...LOL
That's a monster. |
Giant. Congratulations to the lucky hunter. Bet you couldnt wipe the smile off his face with a 2x4 ! Impressive
|
Damm! Very nice
|
Hey RR: Maybe he shot it at 1300 yards and had a hard time field judging from that distace. :D:D
|
Just an update to this thread: On February 9,2010... Mike Ali, Jim Dowd and Gary Dennis of the NYS Big Buck Club panel scored Dave Edwards Cortland County buck. Dave's huge NYS buck scored a whopping 182-0 B&C as a typical with an amazing gross score of 206-0 B&C. The Edwards Buck has 13 typical points and 3 non-typical points and looks to be NY's biggest 2010 typical buck and the #4 all-time |
| All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:23 AM. |
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.