Guess the dressed weight of a few of my deer.
01-12-2009, 04:01 PM
#14
Fork Horn
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 343
RE: Guess the dressed weight of a few of my deer.
ORIGINAL: bronko22000
I would have guess about 10 pounds heavier for each one. I shot some heavy whitetails here in PA. The heaviest weighed in at 154 dressed until this past year. I know this deer dressed out over 200 lbs. One, because I had one heck of a time moving him and hadto call myson to help. And just look at the pic. I am 5'10" and weight 215. This deer dwarfs me.
I would have guess about 10 pounds heavier for each one. I shot some heavy whitetails here in PA. The heaviest weighed in at 154 dressed until this past year. I know this deer dressed out over 200 lbs. One, because I had one heck of a time moving him and hadto call myson to help. And just look at the pic. I am 5'10" and weight 215. This deer dwarfs me.
01-12-2009, 08:15 PM
#15
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Sackets Harbor, New York
Posts: 2,509
RE: Guess the dressed weight of a few of my deer.
I would have guessed a bit higher on those deer.
My buck this year was... 135 or 140, i dont remember exactly. Your deer looked maybe a bit bigger than mine, but pictures on the computer aren't the same as seeing the real thing.
My buck this year was... 135 or 140, i dont remember exactly. Your deer looked maybe a bit bigger than mine, but pictures on the computer aren't the same as seeing the real thing.
01-12-2009, 09:08 PM
#16
Typical Buck
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location:
Posts: 778
RE: Guess the dressed weight of a few of my deer.
ORIGINAL: WestVirginiaBrent
I keep getting heavier too, lol. Seriously though, I state I make a hard shot, give vague details and get called unethical. I state a dead deer I found last year weighs over 220 and get called a liar and an idiot, then I post a buck my buddy killed that dressed well over 200 and get told I don't know anything and that the deer weighs 145 on the hoof.
Here is the pic that prompted me to start this thread. He didn't weigh it but I told him it dress well over 200, my guess would be it dressed 215-220.
ORIGINAL: livbucks
Why do you keep gettingolder in the pictures?
You post the weights and the experts will call you a liar. That's how things work around here.
Why do you keep gettingolder in the pictures?
You post the weights and the experts will call you a liar. That's how things work around here.
Here is the pic that prompted me to start this thread. He didn't weigh it but I told him it dress well over 200, my guess would be it dressed 215-220.
01-12-2009, 10:38 PM
#17
Fork Horn
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 343
RE: Guess the dressed weight of a few of my deer.
ORIGINAL: Vermont_hunter
i would like to ask forgiveness, i shot off too quickly, i should have blwo up the picture to see it better, im still not sure that that deer went 215or in that area but looking at the larger picture(which i should have done before i shot my moulth off) there is a good chance that deer is aound the 200 mark, as for the other deer just looking now i would say around (probably heavier)120for all of them with the eception of your 10 which i was think more around the 140-145 mark....i didn't have time to answer i haven't been on, and if you ment i was the one calling you unethical, i didn't mean it that way at all, just thought i would appoigize for speaking to quickly. it is quite possible im wrong about the weight, and im willing to admit that
ORIGINAL: WestVirginiaBrent
I keep getting heavier too, lol. Seriously though, I state I make a hard shot, give vague details and get called unethical. I state a dead deer I found last year weighs over 220 and get called a liar and an idiot, then I post a buck my buddy killed that dressed well over 200 and get told I don't know anything and that the deer weighs 145 on the hoof.
Here is the pic that prompted me to start this thread. He didn't weigh it but I told him it dress well over 200, my guess would be it dressed 215-220.
ORIGINAL: livbucks
Why do you keep gettingolder in the pictures?
You post the weights and the experts will call you a liar. That's how things work around here.
Why do you keep gettingolder in the pictures?
You post the weights and the experts will call you a liar. That's how things work around here.
Here is the pic that prompted me to start this thread. He didn't weigh it but I told him it dress well over 200, my guess would be it dressed 215-220.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Schultzy
Bowhunting
65
01-06-2009 10:21 AM
TexasOaks
Whitetail Deer Hunting
3
03-08-2007 09:24 PM
