HuntingNet.com Forums

HuntingNet.com Forums (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/)
-   Northeast (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/northeast-26/)
-   -   Mountain lions in PA! (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/northeast/271027-mountain-lions-pa.html)

bluebird2 12-14-2008 07:54 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
It might be BigFoot ,it might be an alien or it might be a fake. Then again it might be the first cat that weighs more than a tractor!!

4evrhtn 12-15-2008 07:41 AM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 

ORIGINAL: BTBowhunter


ORIGINAL: 4evrhtn

I also checked the link BB posted. I see the angle you mention but not every single animal steps with even pressure. I assure you and BT Bowhunter these tracks were not made by me. I don't carry a cougar paw around in my pocket when pheasant hunting to leave impressions and take pictures for something fun to do. I have written before, I have nothing to gain from posting fake pics and why would I?
4evrhtn

I did not mean to imply in any way that you placed that track there!

I merely made an observation that it looked to be too perfect. I still say that. I had no idea of the circumstances surrounding that track. Who photgraphed it? Did you see it in person? Was the PGC or some other organization or experts called in todocument it?
I was the one who took the pic using my cell phone. I was hunting with another guy and he can verify the location of and the validty of it.I can send you his phone number in a PM if that would help.I sent the pics to my brother who has 2 friends in the PAGC central office at Elmerton Drive.They told him they were going to have their bioligists look at it. So far, no word from them. As far as trying to document it by an outside source there was no way for me to do it. We walked down the road leading from a corn field where the farmer had his harvester. After we crossed the creek the farmer came out across the field on his tractor and drove across the creek and up that road. The tracks were probably covered at that point, if I had been there any later than I was I would not have had a chance to see it. I have never seen a print nor a mtn lion in the wild for that matter. It amazes me, the print is too good? If it was a poor print everyone would claim it isn't a cougar. No winning with this group. And to be honest I don't care. Everyone wanted some sort of proof, I provided what I found and now the forensic experts claim there are finger prints and question the weight of a cat in comparison to a tractor. With that logic I guess my shorthair weighs more than my Tundra because you can see clear prints from his paws in the mud I have driven through with my truck. Really... WTF?? But then again I consider source of that implication. Believe it or not, doesn't matter to me, I know what I saw and I have the pics. For everyone's info... my next project is to fake Bigfoots prints and post them here:eek:. Just a head's up of what's coming....:D

sproulman 12-15-2008 09:15 AM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 

ORIGINAL: 4evrhtn


ORIGINAL: BTBowhunter


ORIGINAL: 4evrhtn

I also checked the link BB posted. I see the angle you mention but not every single animal steps with even pressure. I assure you and BT Bowhunter these tracks were not made by me. I don't carry a cougar paw around in my pocket when pheasant hunting to leave impressions and take pictures for something fun to do. I have written before, I have nothing to gain from posting fake pics and why would I?
4evrhtn

I did not mean to imply in any way that you placed that track there!

I merely made an observation that it looked to be too perfect. I still say that. I had no idea of the circumstances surrounding that track. Who photgraphed it? Did you see it in person? Was the PGC or some other organization or experts called in todocument it?
I was the one who took the pic using my cell phone. I was hunting with another guy and he can verify the location of and the validty of it.I can send you his phone number in a PM if that would help.I sent the pics to my brother who has 2 friends in the PAGC central office at Elmerton Drive.They told him they were going to have their bioligists look at it. So far, no word from them. As far as trying to document it by an outside source there was no way for me to do it. We walked down the road leading from a corn field where the farmer had his harvester. After we crossed the creek the farmer came out across the field on his tractor and drove across the creek and up that road. The tracks were probably covered at that point, if I had been there any later than I was I would not have had a chance to see it. I have never seen a print nor a mtn lion in the wild for that matter. It amazes me, the print is too good? If it was a poor print everyone would claim it isn't a cougar. No winning with this group. And to be honest I don't care. Everyone wanted some sort of proof, I provided what I found and now the forensic experts claim there are finger prints and question the weight of a cat in comparison to a tractor. With that logic I guess my shorthair weighs more than my Tundra because you can see clear prints from his paws in the mud I have driven through with my truck. Really... WTF?? But then again I consider source of that implication. Believe it or not, doesn't matter to me, I know what I saw and I have the pics. For everyone's info... my next project is to fake Bigfoots prints and post them here:eek:. Just a head's up of what's coming....:D

thank you for being honest,many believe you.

i too,some dont believe i saw a COUGAR ;)

but i did and waited for the WCO to call me at site i saw it and he did not seem interested and said,SPROUL THEY DONT EXIST.but he did say, I DESCRIBED A COUGAR EVEN THO I TOLD HIM IT LOOKED ORANGISH AND RAN LIKE ONE OF THOSE ORANGE MONKEYS IN AFRICA:D

he said that is called TAWNY.;)


i gave this to cougar network,john lust to look at.

you gave it to the PGC , great, lets see what they tell you it is.;)

i know they do because i saw one.;)

Charlie P 12-15-2008 09:32 AM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
Can't get the pictures to load.

mlo31351270 12-15-2008 09:57 AM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
I just want to point out that the weight of the tractor doesnt even factor in here. Mud is still mud even if you drive through it with a tractorunless it is starting to dry out. As a trapper, I always check the tractor roads for coyote and fox tracks. I have many hundreds of times seencoyote and fox tracks deep into a tractors track. By the way that is a wagon tire track in the picture.

bluebird2 12-15-2008 10:26 AM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
The tractor didn't drive through mud. If it was mud the tires would have sunk in and created ridges along the edges of the track. BTW, if you don't think the weight of a tractor doesn't compact the soil, you don't know much about farming.

mlo31351270 12-15-2008 02:07 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
Of course a tractor compacts soil. Depending on the conditions itmay compact it very little.As the soil driesthere will be more compaction.Thats why the animal track is so deep, the wet soil (mud) is still wet.There is very little compaction in mud. even if it is not deep, like in the picture. I worked on a farm for 18 years I think I should know.

sammy_tat 12-15-2008 02:17 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
Look at the 2 pictures. Compare them and look at the track inprint without the shell and then look at the one with the shell. See any disturbance in the area between them 2 pictures.

BTBowhunter 12-15-2008 02:35 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
Arguing that the track can't be real because it's over a tire print is silly. We all see tracks of many kinds on top of tire tracks. A raccoon cam ake a print right in a truck tire track. Tractor tires are made to "float" or distribute the weight of the machine so that the tires don't sink in soft earth or mud. It is very plausible that any animals track could show up in a tire track like that.

4evr, you say you came upon the track yourself. I asked that specifically because we get so many stories that are second, third, fourth,.... twenty seventh hand accounts of "the facts". You've never given any of us a reason to think you would lie on here that I've seen so my interest just went up a notch or two. It's a shame theprint got destroyed before you could document it. The problem is that we've still not been able to get confirmation even when credible people see or believe they saw something.



4evrhtn 12-15-2008 02:43 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
You have been on here long enough to know Bluebird is an expert at everything when it comes to having a PAGC stat or report to quote. Here he does not and it is apparent he is limited when having to rely on his own common sense to start an argument. I explained to him the weather conditions and apparently he is also an erosion expert as well as a meteorologist (which explains why he is wrong once again). The day before I hunted the area the temperature was warming up and the area where this pic was taken is in a hollow next to a creek and it is swampy there. That day (before I hunted) was when I believe thetire tracks were made.The paw prints could have been made later in the day or earlier the morning we hunted. The day we hunted there the ground was soft and it was warmer still. My 60 pound shorthair made tracks in the same terrain and his prints were also deep and very distinguished on this "compacted soil". Common sense dictates an object of a smaller surface area will make a more pronounced impression in soil than an object much heavier with a greater surface area spreading the weight over a wider surface. But, Mr. Agricultural Farm Equipment Tire Expert and Expert Scout Tracker knows exactly what the conditions were the day the pic was taken without ever stepping foot within miles of the area. Amazing! Don't waste your time debating with him, it's no use.

4evrhtn 12-15-2008 02:49 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 

ORIGINAL: sammy_tat

Look at the 2 pictures. Compare them and look at the track inprint without the shell and then look at the one with the shell. See any disturbance in the area between them 2 pictures.
I had originally taken the first pic without the shell and my buddy and I walked away. He told me we need to get a pic with something showing the relation to the size. We walked back up and laid the shell beside the print and took the second pic. It is possible one of usor my dog disturbed the track when leaving the first time. I noticed this as well (on the toe print on far right side by shell) after I uploaded the pic to my laptop. The second photo was for the purpose of showing the size. The first was taken as "proof".

BTBowhunter 12-15-2008 02:52 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 

Amazing! Don't waste your time debating with him, it's no use.
Absolutely correct. Bluebird is a lost cause. Those of us who debate him don't do it to convince him. That'd be like teaching the proverbial pig to sing. the only good readon for debating him is to point out his little head games so that others don't buy into his load of doo doo.

livbucks 12-15-2008 02:52 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
I believe some are seeing what they claim. Is it possible that a escaped captive cat, that has a few skills, is wandering and giving the appearance of more cats? Who knows!

I have heard, not sure if true...that there are occasional bobcats with tails as log as 14 inches. And I have seen pictures of trapped Bobs that were almost a solid orangy colored with nary a pattern in their coat. Perhaps we are seeing some kind of hybrid super bobcat with cougar bloodlines. They say our yotes are part wolf so it could happen...right?

4evrhtn 12-15-2008 02:56 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 

ORIGINAL: BTBowhunter

4evr, you say you came upon the track yourself. I asked that specifically because we get so many stories that are second, third, fourth,.... twenty seventh hand accounts of "the facts". You've never given any of us a reason to think you would lie on here that I've seen so my interest just went up a notch or two. It's a shame theprint got destroyed before you could document it. The problem is that we've still not been able to get confirmation even when credible people see or believe they saw something.

I wish I could have been able to get someone else out there to check it out. I wonder what type of response time I would have gotten had I called the PAGC and asked to have a warden or someone come out and look into a MTN LION track. I'd probably still be waiting, I can never get anyone to answer the phone when I have called the PAGC.

I will be going back there this upcoming weekend and I am going to scout the area around the creek and areas where there might be undisturbed tracks. If I find one and can document it, I will try to cover it with a milk crate or something to preserve it. I know it is unlikely I will find more tracks but I will try. Maybe take the video camera.

bluebird2 12-15-2008 04:15 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 

Depending on the conditions it may compact it very little. As the soil dries there will be more compaction.
Soil will compact very little if it is very wet or very dry. The soil in the pic wasn't very wet or the tires would have left ruts and it definitely wasn't very dry. Soil does not compact as it dries, but it does become more dense, but it is not due to compaction. Unless the ground froze and thawed before the cat made that track , it is highly unlikely to get such a well defined print from a cat in a tire track.

bluebird2 12-15-2008 04:16 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
The next time you do that will be the first time.

mlo31351270 12-15-2008 04:22 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 

You have been on here long enough to know Bluebird is an expert at everything
Yeah, Ijust found out he is a soil compaction expert. I usually try not to post much when he is involved in a conversation.

bluebird2 12-15-2008 04:37 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
Try harder!!!

livbucks 12-15-2008 04:41 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 

ORIGINAL: mlo31351270


You have been on here long enough to know Bluebird is an expert at everything
Yeah, Ijust found out he is a soil compaction expert. I usually try not to post much when he is involved in a conversation.
His real name is CLIFF CLAVEN. He was wrong anyway. Soil does not become more dense as it dries. It becomes more solid, not more dense. There is less mass density when the moisture content is removed. We learned all this in like 8th Grade. What weighs more BB2....a ton of feathers or a ton of lead?

bluebird2 12-15-2008 04:55 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 


ORIGINAL: livbucks


ORIGINAL: mlo31351270


You have been on here long enough to know Bluebird is an expert at everything
Yeah, I just found out he is a soil compaction expert. I usually try not to post much when he is involved in a conversation.
His real name is CLIFF CLAVEN. He was wrong anyway. Soil does not become more dense as it dries. It becomes more solid, not more dense. There is less mass density when the moisture content is removed. We learned all this in like 8th Grade. What weighs more BB2....a ton of feathers or a ton of lead?
Apparently you flunked eighth grade just as you flunked your test of the PGC code. If the water molecules are removed from the soil by drying it becomes more dense as well as more solid. I learned that in kindergarten.

livbucks 12-15-2008 05:01 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
You confuse density with solidity. Mass density is higher with water content. Take a ball of clay and weigh it. Put it in the oven to dry and then weigh it. Which one has more mass weight?

livbucks 12-15-2008 05:09 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
You could make the dry one denser if you also add compaction under pressure as it dries, but you would also need to add volume as you go. Such as sedimentary rock compressed over eons.

bluebird2 12-15-2008 05:17 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 

Such as sedimentary rock compressed over eons.
Is that the problem with your thought process?
[quoteTake a ball of clay and weigh it. Put it in the oven to dry and then weigh it. Which one has more mass weight?
][/quote]

Which one has the most volume? Density is a measure of weight verses volume. You really don;'t have a clue!


livbucks 12-15-2008 05:22 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
Or I could be wrong. I'm not Cliff Claven, you are.

livbucks 12-15-2008 06:37 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 

ORIGINAL: bluebird2


Such as sedimentary rock compressed over eons.
Is that the problem with your thought process?
[quoteTake a ball of clay and weigh it. Put it in the oven to dry and then weigh it. Which one has more mass weight?

Which one has the most volume? Density is a measure of weight verses volume. You really don;'t have a clue!
The hydrated one has more volume as well. The ball of clay would shrink like your theories on wildlife management.

BTBowhunter 12-15-2008 06:39 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
I think Cliffy's in over his head again!:eek:

bluebird2 12-15-2008 06:43 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 

The hydrated one has more volume as well. The ball of clay would shrink like your theories on wildlife management.
All of my predictions about wildlife management have come true. You can't even follow the regs no less predict the results of the deer management plan.

livbucks 12-15-2008 06:50 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
I can predict I have zero chance of sighting you in the woods. I can also predict that if the economy continues to decline, and the herd increases...deer meat will become a hot commodity...lots of hunters once again shooting lots of deer.
I have no idea why you worry about too many deer, when you have been complaining about too few since I came here in 2004.

BTBowhunter 12-15-2008 06:51 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
yuns guyz keep an eye on bb. I'z goin ta bed. Tomoro iz gunna be da only day widout rain and im goin huntin fer anudder doe in 2B. I'l bee watchin fur deer trax inside uv tyre trax cuz now I knowd dat theyd be from a really hevy deer. BB sed so!

livbucks 12-15-2008 06:58 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
Nighty...

(Stay away from the nighty or you'll be too tired in the AM.;))

BTBowhunter 12-15-2008 07:03 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 

Nighty...

(Stay away from the nighty or you'll be too tired in the AM.;))


no worries it's not my birthday!

livbucks 12-15-2008 07:10 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
My equivalent would be onour anniversary, provided I did and said precisely all the correct things over the course of the day. I mess up on purpose because our anniversary falls in the first week of November.
I do have priorities.
The bucks don't wait.

sproulman 12-15-2008 08:05 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 

ORIGINAL: 4evrhtn


ORIGINAL: BTBowhunter

4evr, you say you came upon the track yourself. I asked that specifically because we get so many stories that are second, third, fourth,.... twenty seventh hand accounts of "the facts". You've never given any of us a reason to think you would lie on here that I've seen so my interest just went up a notch or two. It's a shame theprint got destroyed before you could document it. The problem is that we've still not been able to get confirmation even when credible people see or believe they saw something.

I wish I could have been able to get someone else out there to check it out. I wonder what type of response time I would have gotten had I called the PAGC and asked to have a warden or someone come out and look into a MTN LION track. I'd probably still be waiting, I can never get anyone to answer the phone when I have called the PAGC.

I will be going back there this upcoming weekend and I am going to scout the area around the creek and areas where there might be undisturbed tracks. If I find one and can document it, I will try to cover it with a milk crate or something to preserve it. I know it is unlikely I will find more tracks but I will try. Maybe take the video camera.
we had expert look at picture of track and it is DOG TRACK, SORRY TO SAY BUT FOR SOMEONE THAT HAS NOT SEEN TRACK LIKE THAT TOO, IT CAME ACCROSS AS UNUSUAL DO TO ITS SIZE ETC.

BUT ITS DOG TRACK .;)

livbucks 12-15-2008 09:02 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
Somebody musta declawed that dog then.

sproulman 12-15-2008 09:20 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 

ORIGINAL: livbucks

Somebody musta declawed that dog then.
good point.

but expert looked at it for me that has seen cougar tracks a LOT and he says its a DOG.

i would like to say its a COUGAR;)but i would not be honest to all of us and my reputation is important to me.

i hope the PGC gives opinion too.

i hate to beNEGATIVE on this but that is best print i have seen in mud in long time and no way that print is fake,just we think its DOG and a big one at that:D

moose1915 12-16-2008 12:47 AM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
there's a shocker...

Screamin Steel 12-16-2008 01:16 AM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
A canine track has a triangular shaped center pad, the pad of a cat track has three distinct lobes, like a three leafed clover. Unless the dog was declawed, as has been suggested, his claws would be clearly visible in the track. A cat track may or may not show claws as theirs are retractable. An adult cougar track is roughly the size of an adult german shepherd track.


4evrhtn 12-16-2008 04:53 AM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
Thanks Sproul for the effort. I will accept that print as canine b/c there is nothing but speculation to think otherwise. I will say having seen the print in person that is a damn big dog and just as much a threat to wild game, if he is without owner he is history. We have enough coyotes running around we don't need 160 lb dogs roaming the woods too.

If I ever hear from the PAGC, I will let you know. Betting they say monster bobcat... any takers?

Charlie P 12-16-2008 10:00 AM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 

[quote]BUT ITS DOG TRACK[/quote]

They must have had a good weed harvest this year with some of these posts.

bluebird2 12-16-2008 04:29 PM

RE: Mountain lions in PA!
 
Based on this link I'd say Sproul's expert is dead wrong.

http://www.bear-tracker.com/dog.html




All times are GMT -8. The time now is 03:32 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.