HuntingNet.com Forums

HuntingNet.com Forums (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/)
-   Northeast (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/northeast-26/)
-   -   33 deer in 4 days (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/northeast/123368-33-deer-4-days.html)

Jim Beam 12-02-2005 12:34 AM

33 deer in 4 days
 
Our camp,all family members to boot took 33 deer in 4 days from private and sgl land. 10 was 4 points or smaller 3 was 6 to 9 pointers and the rest was does. 22 of us alltogether. We still have8 doe tags to fill and9 adult buck tags.Our 100 acre is adjacent to sgl and we just posted sitters there and put drives on.Last year we got 50+ deer but had a few more hunters.I know for sure that there are less quality in bucks than last year.I will post pics of the 33 deers when I find the usb cable.Maybe by saturday when I go back up they might have a few more hanging.These picslook like back in the times when you see all them hunters sitting in front of the poles with all them deer behind them.It's really a moment in time spent with family.

Jim Beam 12-02-2005 12:47 AM

RE: 33 deer in 4 days
 
Oh,that was what a read from another forumI visited tonite.I didn't finish before I hit send. Now I think that is way out of control there.

They have theire own property yet they go to SGL and drive the deer offSGL onto theire property. What the hell is that? There should be some kind of law for behavior like that. Upsets many who don't have private land to hunt on.

mounting man 12-02-2005 05:12 AM

RE: 33 deer in 4 days
 
What state were they in????? It sure wern't Pa!!10 four points=illegal kills,in Pa?
Also,it sounds like a fairy tale.

tj_cubin 12-02-2005 06:30 AM

RE: 33 deer in 4 days
 
they shot more deer than they had hunters in four days, and they are complaining?

IMO, they should lose their huning licenses for a year, then the next year they might not take it for granted and actually appreciate what they can get.

Pa Trophy Man 12-02-2005 06:34 AM

RE: 33 deer in 4 days
 
You are hunting in PA?

mossy33oak 12-02-2005 07:24 AM

RE: 33 deer in 4 days
 

ORIGINAL: Jim Beam

Our camp,all family members to boot took 33 deer in 4 days


I know for sure that there are less quality in bucks than last year.
I wonder why????? 10 deer 4 pts or less.....[:'(][:'(][:@]

Deersmoker243 12-02-2005 07:55 AM

RE: 33 deer in 4 days
 

What state were they in????? It sure wern't Pa!!10 four points=illegal kills,in Pa?
Also,it sounds like a fairy tale.
Antler restrictions dont apply to kids so if they had 10 kids with there youth tags it would have been legal...i do think it is some what of a fairy tale though...

GREEK HUNTER 12-02-2005 08:06 AM

RE: 33 deer in 4 days
 
see if that was my land i would have my own regs and would be producing big bucks and only taking mature doe's... in a few yrs there going to ask there self the question where did all the deer go? then there going to say oh yeah we killed them all off.

villeman 12-02-2005 10:40 AM

RE: 33 deer in 4 days
 
Sounds like what happened in my hunting area last year. I hunt in Huntingdon County on SGL and my Dad talked to a local guy the first day of rifle season; who said a group of local hunters drove the area for a week and took 25 doe. Now I know why we didn't see as many deer this year in archery. Thats a lot of deer to take in one area, I don't care where it is.



PABuck_HNTR 12-02-2005 06:44 PM

RE: 33 deer in 4 days
 
Not really the kind of post that will get positive replies around here. 22 guys 33 deer? sounds like some people are a bit greedy

Rebel Hog 12-03-2005 05:08 AM

RE: 33 deer in 4 days
 

ORIGINAL: mossy33oak


ORIGINAL: Jim Beam

Our camp,all family members to boot took 33 deer in 4 days


I know for sure that there are less quality in bucks than last year.
I wonder why????? 10 deer 4 pts or less.....[:'(][:'(][:@]





Ditto,Ditto,Ditto!

djgj200 12-03-2005 03:30 PM

RE: 33 deer in 4 days
 
I am lost. It sounds like in Jim's post that he was in the group with all of those deer taken and is upset. Someone clarify this for me because I am not getting it.

I hunt private land in Southern NY through a hunting club and it too abutts state land and it doesn't seem like they cross the boundary onto our land until you can see the footprints in the snow. When we occupy the land with hunters they post along the line, somebody even put upa tree stand right on the line facing into our land. A guy that lives on the border of the land has been caught many times trespassing on our land and will stare you down.

I would put up a barbed wire fence high enough to keep the guys out but low enough so the deer could cross. But it is too much money to fence up such a large piece of land.

tj_cubin 12-03-2005 04:20 PM

RE: 33 deer in 4 days
 

I am lost. It sounds like in Jim's post that he was in the group with all of those deer taken and is upset. Someone clarify this for me because I am not getting it.
read the first reply on this topic that was by jim explaining it, he said:

Oh,that was what a read from another forumI visited tonite.I didn't finish before I hit send. Now I think that is way out of control there.

djgj200 12-03-2005 04:28 PM

RE: 33 deer in 4 days
 
Oh, thanks a bunch. I figured I missed something.

Mr. Longbeard 12-04-2005 02:45 PM

RE: 33 deer in 4 days
 
I rest my case again on private propertry!!!!

Sounds like some real deer hunters hunting that there private property

Thank god for private land huh???

germain 12-04-2005 06:46 PM

RE: 33 deer in 4 days
 
I think the poster is just stirring the pot.I say horse pucky!

djgj200 12-04-2005 06:57 PM

RE: 33 deer in 4 days
 
It is no lie. If you ever talk to anyone from the Owl Creek club, they will tell you.

germain 12-04-2005 07:12 PM

RE: 33 deer in 4 days
 
Where is this club?

djgj200 12-04-2005 07:25 PM

RE: 33 deer in 4 days
 
I think it is in Spencer, NY. They have lease land in Spencer and Caroline. I just have ties to the secretary and he tells me what I need to get to him, I get it to him and he takes care of the rest.

fatsbucknut 12-04-2005 07:28 PM

RE: 33 deer in 4 days
 
I live near Lake Raystown and a group of 20 amish guys around my house have killed 12 legal bucks so far and i'm not sure about doe harvest but i'm sure they've killed just as many if not more. This is all on public land

Rebel Hog 12-04-2005 07:52 PM

RE: 33 deer in 4 days
 

ORIGINAL: germain

I think the poster is just stirring the pot.I say horse pucky!

Horse Pucky?




mossy33oak 12-05-2005 01:07 AM

RE: 33 deer in 4 days
 

ORIGINAL: fatsbucknut

I live near Lake Raystown and a group of 20 amish guys around my house have killed 12 legal bucks so far and i'm not sure about doe harvest but i'm sure they've killed just as many if not more. This is all on public land
seriously, how do Amish hunt??? old muzzleloaders or new rifles or bows??? Im curious.

Rebel Hog 12-05-2005 01:19 AM

RE: 33 deer in 4 days
 

ORIGINAL: mossy33oak


ORIGINAL: fatsbucknut

I live near Lake Raystown and a group of 20 amish guys around my house have killed 12 legal bucks so far and i'm not sure about doe harvest but i'm sure they've killed just as many if not more. This is all on public land
seriously, how do Amish hunt??? old muzzleloaders or new rifles or bows??? Im curious.

:D:DMossy, they have God to show them!:D:D


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 05:38 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.