HuntingNet.com Forums

HuntingNet.com Forums (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/)

- Midwest (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/midwest-25/)

- - C.W.D. (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/midwest/7310-c-w-d.html)

Fresh from Madison, 3 confirmed cases found in deer harvested around Mt. Horeb during gun season. Unit 70a, I was told.

I don't think these 3 will originate from a pen. I live a few miles from Mt. Horeb and know of none in the neighborhood. It will be interesting to see the rest of the facts when they become available.

Talk about close to hitting close to home. I heard at least one of the three were taken in the Town of Vermont. That guys and gals would be right out my front door. I may have to give up my fight against T Zones and KILL THEM ALL.<img src=icon_smile_dissapprove.gif border=0 align=middle><img src=icon_smile_dissapprove.gif border=0 align=middle><img src=icon_smile_dissapprove.gif border=0 align=middle><img src=icon_smile_dissapprove.gif border=0 align=middle><img src=icon_smile_angry.gif border=0 align=middle><img src=icon_smile_dissapprove.gif border=0 align=middle><img src=icon_smile_dissapprove.gif border=0 align=middle><img src=icon_smile_dissapprove.gif border=0 align=middle>

I take it that is the DNR flying overhead in helicopters. Thursday, they were flying low above all the farms and houses then hovering above the wood lots. I hear a lot of deer will be taken out for testing. It has begun.

Yeah I read 500 more deer instead of 100 in milwaukee journal online.
Sucks. I know 70B last spring had a heck of alot of deer around when I was turkey hunting. Seemed a bit over crowded the fields near Portage. I will be hunting Turkey again this spring and see if its like that again. After what I seen last year i stated that 70b should of been a tzone. and it was. I see this year it isnt. I will let ya know what i see. To many make disease.

Peak
Live and Learn

CWD is in 70a, not 70b.

I know its 70a, but it could happen if to many deer like I saw in 70b.

Peak
Live and Learn

See the outlined box on the right? I assume this is one of the kill areas since I'm familier with one of the farms the infected deer came from. I'd be about 2.5 miles N of that box.<img src=icon_smile_dissapprove.gif border=0 align=middle>

Nub your more then welcome to come and hunt a farm in 70B if they end up wiping out 70A.

Peak
Live and Learn

Thanks for the offer Peak. Depending on how far they want to lower the density around hear, I may need to find a new place to hunt. Good thing I filled my freezer with Moose last fall or I'd have a freezer full of Whitetail. With a little luck it will be full of Moose again next fall and I won't have to worry about eating this suspect venison from my neighborhood. Guess I'll just keep my fingers crossed and hope for the best.

NOTE TO ALL: This does not mean I feel the DNR knows how to count deer. If they say this is from over population, I'm not buying it. If they say this area needs to be killed out to control CWD and protect the rest of the state, I'll do my part. <img src=icon_smile_sad.gif border=0 align=middle>

Nub I have heard that some of the deer taken this week showed signs of advanced stages.(wasting away, skin and bones) did you hear anything about this or the three bucks that where taken in Nov. as to weather they showed signs?
I wouldnt be afraid to eat the deer you shot this fall. CWD has been out west for over 16 years and noone has caught it. they have even injected CWD material into liveing cows brains and found that it doesnt spread to the new host.
But if you ain't going to eat it let me know when to come over and pick it up! <img src=icon_smile_clown.gif border=0 align=middle> <img src=icon_smile_big.gif border=0 align=middle>

cheese: I heard from a freind that one of the first bucks taken showed signs of being sick. The only thing I've heard since is a few gunshots. I've already eaten half of the deer I took last year so I might as well finish it off.<img src=icon_smile_dead.gif border=0 align=middle>

trapper: I believe they tested 82 deer from Mt. Horeb and about 1000 in the entire state. Soon to be another 500 or so from this area.

Good luck people im from the east hope it doesnt come to P.A. we have millions of whitetails here and some elk its a very sad thing <img src=icon_smile_sad.gif border=0 align=middle>

I couldn't make the Mt. Horeb meeting but a buddy of mine did attend. He said they were told that CWD has in 1 instance out west, jumped to humans. This is not good news. The person who contracted the disease was over sixty and died from it. Apparently once symtems occur, your toast within 18 months. Can any one else confirm this? Seems of the 180 deer they have taken so far, most have been does and fawns. The CWD was found in 3.5 yr. old bucks. Could be kind of hard this time of year to target those age class deer with their horns being dropped. My freind will be making me copies of the hand outs from the meeting and I will try and scan them and post them as soon as I can get them.

Sorry guys...untrue.

There is no scientific evidence to support the claim that CWD has jumped the genetic barrier to humans. There is no evidence that it has crossed the genetic barrier to domestic livestock either. But if it does at some point in the future, then woe is us.

Test results from the first bach should be in april 1st. This is not soon enough for me.

An interesting read for you. Thanks Mat
Lately there has been some conflicting information on CWD being reported in the media. This includes statements such as "little is known about CWD" or "we don't know how CWD is spread." The following is a response to a WDHA inquiry about the current state of knowledge on CWD. This was written by Professor Val Geist from the University of Calgary, who is considered one of the world's leading experts on CWD. It is also posted on the WDHA website.

Dear Mr. Toso, I shall comment on the CWD issues that concern you, but before I do so you need to be aware of my qualifications and motives. My narrow field of scientific expertise is the behavior, ecology and evolutionary history of cloven-hoofed mammals, the deer and bovid family in particular. I also have some expertise in and have taught and published on wildlife conservation policy and management. I became aware of CWD as a potential conservation problem for free-living cervids very early after its discovery. I have had some time to get to know it. I have followed the European BSE controversy closely, having the advantage of reading and speaking German and thus having access to not only scholarly writings but the excellent investigative reporting of Germany's foremost weekly, DER SPIEGEL, which has displayed a consistent and very informed interest in the mad cow issue. I know the foremost of our American researchers into CWD and have had contacts with them, and have been with them in common court cases. I have published on the matter of CWD in relation to game farming and its policy implications in the second chapter of Geist, V. and I. McTaggart Cowan (eds.1995) Wildlife Conservation Policy. (Detselig, Calgary. You may call Mr. Ted Giles, the publisher, at 403-283-0900 to obtain a copy, unless such is in a university library close by. This book is not unimportant in current context). Precisely because I have an understanding of what free-living deer do and where they do it, I can see and discuss links to CWD research, and come to insights foreclosed to veterinarians who deal with deer in captivity. Moreover, both agricultural and wildlife veterinarians have currently very much at stake, and their pronouncements are - unfortunately - colored by their fears and occasionally by crucial misjudgments. Unless veracity is practiced I am afraid that we as scientists may be branded as scoundrels, as DER SPIEGEL did with those that handled the PR on BSE in England. Let me state from the outset, CWD can be defeated and eradicated. However, whether the cure is palatable to all concerned, is another matter. Chronic Wasting Disease (CWD) is a Transmissible Spongiform Encephalopathy (TSE) a sister-disease to Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (BSE) or mad cow disease. That is, in its known characteristics, it is quite close to BSE - as we shall see below. The statement that CWD is "species specific" is false. I occurs in elk, mule deer and white-tailed deer. Elk not only belong to different species than mule deer or white-tailed deer, but to a different genus and a different subfamily, the Cervinae or Old World deer. These are very different from the New World Deer to which belong mule deer and white-tailed deer, two separate species in their own rights. Our currently best hypothesis is that CWD arose from scrapie, a TSE found in sheep, a stable and for humans apparently not infective form of TSE. From sheep, CWD jumped to mule deer, then to elk, and then to white-tailed deer. The theoretical significance is that with each jump one expects its infectivity to increase. CWD has been experimentally transferred to various species including among other mink, cattle and squirrel monkeys. What is missing to date are in vivo studies on laboratory Old World primates fed oral dosages of CWD infected tissues. Such studies, carried out with BSE, proved to be predictive for BSE infecting humans, a number of years before the first case of new variant Creutzfeld-Jakob Disease (CJD) was found in humans. nvCJD is one of four variants of TSE's in humans. There is also talk of a "species barrier" as if this barrier is absolute. It is not. It is a relative barrier. In vitro (test tube) experiments have shown that deformed or pathologic CWD prions (the infective agent) convert healthy human prions at about the same rate as do pathological BSE prions. In both cases it is about 7 (seven) percent. The rate at which defective human CJD prions convert healthy ones into pathological ones is taken as 100 percent. If we are concerned about BSE we cannot be cavalier with CWD. A half-truth perpetrated by agencies is that no humans have been found with a CJD that has come from CWD. A half-truth is a technically correct statement that is misleading. Moreover, it is based on a gross misjudgment, confusing detectability with infectivity. For BSE - the standard of comparison - there are good connections to CJD, and uncritical comparisons are made to it discussing the infectivity of CWD. However, that's comparing apples and oranges. the epidemiological factors concerning BSE and CWD are vastly different, making it very unlikely that a CWD caused CJD would be discovered. Let's go through the epidemiological factors one by one. There are at least ten that preclude a ready comparison, however before discussing these one must know tissues of prion concentration. Prions are most highly concentrated in metabolically very active tissues such as brain, neural tissues, bone marrow, the lining of the gut, lymphatic tissues, to a lesser extend in blood and least of all in muscle meat. If the rule holds, that prions are produced massively in highly active tissues than velvet deer antlers are primary candidates for CWD infectivity. Here are the epidemiological factors making detection of CWD unlikely. 1. The geographic area with CWD is found in the USA is a tiny fraction of are in Great Britain (UK) contaminated with BSE. 2. The human population density in our CWD area is very low compared to the population density in the UK. 3. Beef is a commercial staple in the UK; venison in the US is not. 4. Beef brains in the UK went into sausage; deer brains in the US do not. Nor are deer brains sold here as a delicacy as beef or calf brains are in Europe. 5. Beef blood in the UK is used for blood pudding or blood and tongue sausages; deer blood normally stays in the field. 6. Lymph nodes in butchered beef go to processed meats; deer lymph nodes are cut out and thrown away. 7. Beef rumen and intestine may be eaten as tripe or sausage casings; American hunters do not eat the guts of deer. 8. Beef bones sold for stock (marrow very infective); deer bones are here not frequently used for stock (though I do) 9. Where do cow udders go in a butchering plant? They are very likely a most infective tissue. Here deer udders go to the dog or to the dump. 10. CJD easily confused with other dementias and under-reported in UK by one order of magnitude. Do you expect better detection in the back country of Colorado, Wyoming or Nebraska? Therefore, the probability of detecting a CWD caused CJD infection is low, but the probability of infection is unknown - and the two must not be confused. However, they are continually confused! What to do about CWD? Observations on captive herds indicate lateral transmission probably via super-saturation of the facilities with infective prions originating in the faces (gut-lining) or body fluids. the implications for free-living deer is that artificial feeding, watering and salting sites will transmit the disease. At least until the earth surface has been rinsed by rains and melting snow and the diseased prions are dissipated into the soil beyond any reach by deer. A second source, obvious to those who have observed free-living deer or elk is that they chew bones. Even if the bone marrow and brain rot inside bones, a dried tissue residue remains inside well-protected against the elements, particularly within marrow bones. Consequently, the scattered bones of deer dying of CWD are likely to remain infective agents for a very, very long time. Consequently, one must find a way to find and destroy bones of deer deceased in the free state. It could be done by teams of sportsmen with trained dogs - a Herculean task, no doubt, but a feasible one - for sportsmen, not for the DNR or agricultural bureaucracies. An owner of a farm can scour his land most effectively as he or she will know where deer hand out. Such bones must be destroyed with in a high temperature incinerator. Depopulating deer populations without removing the bones of deer that died naturally will not be effective in eliminating CWD. Personally? Do not eat obviously sick deer. Debone the healthy ones using a knife only and discard bones and internal organs into incineration. Do not saw through bone marrow and back bone, spraying marrow and spinal chord on meat. Use knife only (old style European butchering. Gives a superior cut anyway). Give head away for testing, if negative, eat deer with relish. I case of doubt give it to man's best friend. Sincerely, Val Geist Professor Emeritus of Environmental Science The University of Calgary

Great information. Thanks Mark.

There are now 12 cases of CWD according to todays paper.

Bump for pig dog02

This is an updated map from 4/5/02. I'm not sure if the 2 new positives are included. My section is now bordered on 2 sides with positive tests.

Edited by - nub on 04/08/2002 11:50:19

CWD will change the way we hunt dramatically. First baiting deer will be banned. Baitng has been a big controversy for years but will end this year. Second deer and elk farms are not the problem. These ranchers go through great lengths to protect there very large investment and have been optionally and now required to test butchered animals for CWD. These tests can't be obviously made wild animals. Ranchers and the state are trying to fund not only a Wisconsin based testing center (currently in Iowa only), but also developing a way to test on live animals. The third and final point is obvious- The herd is just out of control. I think we need to do the following: We need to reach a compromise with the snowmobile lobby who are well organized and have stopped extention of the Whitetail season into January. The compromise is simple. The northern part of the state has by far the best snowmobiling in the state. Close the deer season for the top 1/4 of the state on 12/31. The bottom 3/4 of the state where largest part of the herd is concentrated,we extend the season until the last day of January. Also, to end the T-zone war between bow hunters and gun hunters, We allow for bow hunters to take a doe a day (one buck tag) throughout the season. DQM will love this also. No zone T's. The rifle season should begin on November 15th and run for two weeks straight. Again generous FREE tags for the southern 3/4 units. IF YOU DON'T HAVE ROOM IN YOUR FREEZER, DONATE IT.

The biggest point the state and hunters must promote is the fact that in 30 years of research of CWD in animals as well as the current animals being tested, NO EVIDENCE OF CWD AFFECTING THE MEAT.

HUNTERS MUST STAY UNITED ON THIS EFFORT . ANTI'S ARE LOOKING FOR ANY OPPORTUNITY TO PUT A CHINK IN OUR ARMOR. TO BE DIVIDED IS TO BE CONQURED.

-REMI700

remi700: Interesting point of view. Deer and Elk farms not a problem? With them as a documented problem out west, people on the net seem to be placing a lot of the blame that way. Donate the meat? What butcher around here is going to process it? I live in CWD central in case you didn't see that. Right next to those 7 pretty little red squares on the preceeding map. Personnaly the DNR has to come up with a good plan before I go hunting just to kill a deer. Providing I survive the deer I already ate, I'm not going to eat another unless a local test is readily available. You will not see my name as the first case of CWD making the jump to humans. The same holds true with all the others in my area I've talked to. This is gonna get a lot worse before it gets better.

Nub, I havn't eaten any red meat but venison, elk and buffalo for over the past 12 years. I have had no negative effects. I have zero concerns about the meat from any of these animals. Tell me how elk in captivity have spread CWD to wild whitetails if they can't range on the same agriculture and spread the disease? If elk, for example get out, which is very rare,they return rather quickly inside the fences. Because of there herd mentality and second the grains they are getting inside is easier to get and they don't know what to eat often times on the outside because it isn't what they have been eating for there entire life. I can't make the same claim for pen raised deer, but I would assume the same behavior. Also, the Professors point about sending your deer brain off to be tested before you consume is moronic. The maximum capacity of the only testing facility in the midwest (Iowa) is 15,000 a year. Wisconsin hunters alone shoot 300,000 + a year. They would have to build at least twenty of these research facilities in our state alone to handle the test load. The already over burderns Wisconsin( 3rd highest in the US) won't stand for it so hunters venison will be 100% gaurenteed. Also, the anti-hunters and the left wing media are going to eat this up.

Beyond that, if you think you are at "ground zero" in Mt.Horeb , think again. CWD is more than likely statewide, however more so in the bottom 3/4 of the state. But if CWD has been around for 30-40 years and we are just becomming more more focused on it, how come we havn't had an explosion of venison eaters being negatively affected health wise by CWD?

Do what you want, but until the research is sound that determines that CWD is being passed on to humans, I'm eating my venison and ranch raised elk.

I just heard on the news that of the 500 shot, they have 12 confirmed cases of CWD or 2.4% of those tested ? Is that correct?

Remi700

remi: If you think deer and elk farms have nothing to do with the spread of CWD I suggest you read everything you can find on CWD. I talked to a biologist from the DNR at our annual club meeting last night and was informed that in fact 20 pen raised elk were introduced into the state in 95 I believe. These elk were discovered to have CWD in 1999.

There are now 13 confirmed cases of CWD. Minus the first 3 that were not from the test sample (killed during deer season, not the test) the remaining 10 positives came from about 295 samples. We can expect to see the testing to expand around those satalite positives. Remember that about 10 of these positives seem to be in a small area. Also consider that the same area had 3 deer per section taken for testing compared to as little as 1 or none in the surrounding area. The way the test is set up, there should be more positives in the group because more deer were from that area. A flaw if you ask me in determining an accurate %.

You people eat the meat if you want, not me unless I can get a test. Coming soon to WI. I was told is our own testing facility. It has already been proven that prions can be found in muscle tissue. Read some of the back threads and you will find the story. We eat muscle tissue.

Sorry forgot to add; The age of the positives ranged from a doe soon to be 2 yrs old to the oldest doe which was 8 years old. CWD is now just accross the fence from my tree stand. The last doe I took had just jumped that fence.

Edited by - nub on 04/10/2002 07:37:13

Nub, Thanks for the update. Did the DNR agent inform you on how a pen confined elk can possibly transmit saliva/urine to wild whitetails? That seems highly unlikely. Since farmers have known about CWD for 30+ years in sheep and the DNR has also suspectedit to be in the deer population for almost as long, why are elk ranches that popped up primarily in the mid 90's the blame? Confused at the logic behind that finger pointing. I have read extensive arguments and strategies from all sides of this serious debate as it has a monumental impact on myself and my family. As stated before, I eat almost exclusively elk, buffalo, venison, pheasant, duck and wild turkey. At the Whitetail/turkey show in Madison this past weekend, I spoke to three DNR agents at there booth. Not one of them could answer my above question and the two older agents confirmed the fact the DNR has known about CWD for at least 20 years.

I think it still boils down to one simple point. We have to many deer in the state and we need to be aggressive about lowering the population. We also need to ban baiting and feeding.

I hope you are correct that the CWD is concentrated in the main testing area. This would make the new testing facilities job and the overall situation much more controlable.

I havn't had a chance to speak with anyone from the Ozaukee county conservation meeting on Monday. Anything new on the many proposals?

-Remi700

that is a bad thing.... man hope it stays away and does not spread very much