HuntingNet.com Forums

HuntingNet.com Forums (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/)
-   Guns (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/guns-10/)
-   -   NEW .17 HMR (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/guns/267689-new-17-hmr.html)

scottk2008 10-12-2008 02:26 PM

NEW .17 HMR
 
I have been looking at buying a new .17HMR. I was looking at the Ruger, and I also looked at a Sako (which is big bucks). I was wondering if anyone has a Ruger and how it shoots. Also how is this overall caliber. I thought I might buy one just to shoot with at the range and to do some ground hog hunting with. Are they worth the money or should I just save my wifes money. LOL

rshunter32 10-12-2008 04:22 PM

RE: NEW .17 HMR
 
I own a marlin .17 and absolutely love it. Knockin down dogs at 100-200 yrds is too much fun. Unless you need to have the fancy stocks and high end names, for 1/2 the $ or less you can pick up a Marlin or Savage that will shoot just as good.

Retaks 10-12-2008 04:26 PM

RE: NEW .17 HMR
 
Save some money and get a Marlin and put a good Timney trigger in it.

Rebel Hog 10-12-2008 07:01 PM

RE: NEW .17 HMR
 
CZ

legion 10-12-2008 07:47 PM

RE: NEW .17 HMR
 
I have the Savage 93 and I love it.

rifle_man 10-12-2008 08:03 PM

RE: NEW .17 HMR
 
Go with a Savage 93

goatbrother 10-12-2008 09:15 PM

RE: NEW .17 HMR
 
A Marlin 917V is hard to beat.

coyote#68 10-12-2008 09:36 PM

RE: NEW .17 HMR
 
I owned a marlin when they first came out.The accuracy was great,less than a 1/2 inch at a hundred yards.This would be an excellent groundhog gun for closer ranges to 175yards or so,but you will have a few runners if you cant hit them in the head,as far as the ruger goes I'm sure that it would be a great rifle the 77/22 is an awesome gun,as someone else said CZ,I have a CZ 452 american and this is hands down the best made 22 rifle I have owned,I have a 9 and1/2 oz trigger and this gun will outshoot my rem.541T and at $300 new it would be impossible to find a ruger for that price in 17hmr.Marlin,savage, and CZ make a great 17hmr gun for half the price of the ruger or sako guns that will shoot just as well,the CZ will be very comparable too the ruger but a little less expensive.I dont know about kimber or anschultz,but if the sako and ruger are expensive then you best stay away from these!I would love to own a kimber but I won't give what they wan't for one.

2FNSLO 10-14-2008 10:42 AM

RE: NEW .17 HMR
 
Another vote for the Savage 93 here. Very accurate rifle with the accu trigger. I say save the money on a rifle and spend it on good glass to see those tiny little holes out to 100 yards. I haven't shot a ground hog with mine yet, but it is really too much for the tree rats. (unless you head shoot them)

Lanse couche couche 10-14-2008 11:01 AM

RE: NEW .17 HMR
 
Funny, i keep seeing folks say that the .17 isn't good for squirrels. I prefer to take head shots, but have taken several with shots thru the shoulder.Except for losing a couple square inches of rib meat, there has not been a problem. Most of the good meat on a squirrel is the hindlegs and lower back, so you have a lot of room for error even if you are shooting them with a centerfire.

bronko22000 10-14-2008 11:12 AM

RE: NEW .17 HMR
 
I took my Savage on several squirrel hunts last year and had a blast. After the first time I decided to limit myself to only taking head shots (The rifle is so accurate that this seemed only fair to the squirrels). I got a bunch of them at ranges out to 75 or 80 yds. It really diciplines your shooting skills and patience.

sngehl01 10-14-2008 08:07 PM

RE: NEW .17 HMR
 
another vote for the savage 93

I have one w/out an accutrigger and love it.

Get some FMJ's and feel free to shoot a squirrel where ever, it doesn't destroy much... the BT's and HP's on the other hand... wow

tsonka 11-01-2008 06:03 AM

RE: NEW .17 HMR
 
Gonna hop into this thread instead of starting a new one.

Im about to pull the trigger and buy a Remington Model 5 .17HMR

I see very little on the forums about this rifle, anyone have one? What ya think of it?

Colorado Luckydog 11-01-2008 08:35 AM

RE: NEW .17 HMR
 

ORIGINAL: goatbrother

A Marlin 917V is hard to beat.
X2 I had the Savage and just didn't think it shot as good as the Marlin. However, I have a Savage .223 that is one of the most accurate guns I own, right out of the box. I love the accu trigger.

goatbrother 11-01-2008 11:59 AM

RE: NEW .17 HMR
 

ORIGINAL: tsonka

Gonna hop into this thread instead of starting a new one.

Im about to pull the trigger and buy a Remington Model 5 .17HMR

I see very little on the forums about this rifle, anyone have one? What ya think of it?
Take a look around at rimfrecentral.com before you buy that Remy. http://www.rimfirecentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=221908&highlight=model+5

tsonka 11-02-2008 02:31 PM

RE: NEW .17 HMR
 
Thank you for the reply.

After posting here I did some more research and discovered that the Remington model 5 is not made by Remington so that firearm lost some of its appeal. Now Im not saying its a bad gun its just that I have a model 700 that I love and I was looking at the Model 5 thinking it was a Remington made by Remington.

Now that I have that new piece of information I am looking at the Savage Model 93 with the SS bull barrel, Model 93R17-FVSS.

I have a question about that rifle that Im gonna ask here but may start a new thread if needed to get an answer.

I am not a fan of plastic on my firearms. I wish that Savage offered the Model 93R17 Classic with a SS Bull Barrel. I was going to email them and ask them if the stock off the Model 93R17 Classic would hold the componets of the FVSS, and if so could I buy the wooden stock of the classic and swap the parts over. Savage does not accept email:( Does anyone know the answer to that question?


Thank you for the rimfire forum site. That forum is new to me.



Another question Im going to ask here to avoid a new thread. All of my firerarms serve a purpose.

Ruger 10/22 - Small Game
Remington 700- Deer
Remington 870 - Shotgun
Smith and Wesson 44mag - Dresser Drawer
Browning Buckmark II and Ruger mark II - plinking

The idea for the .17HMR is this.

I spend time each weekend at the 100 yard shooting range with my friends and ammo cost is starting to wear on me. I like to shoot, caliber is not an issue with me when target shooting, I would use my .22 on the 100 yard range if it wasnt for the fact that my scope is set at50 yards. I an wanting a rifle that is suitable for 100 yards with a reasonable ammo cost when it comes to shooting 100 rounds a weekend (yes that sounds like alot but my shooting partners have AR-15's and go through that much ammo quickly). I shot my uncle's .17HMR and think that I have found my gun but someone suggested the .22mag and tossed that into the mix. I am still pro .17HMR but I do not want to rule out anything.


outdoorsmen 11-03-2008 10:00 AM

RE: NEW .17 HMR
 

ORIGINAL: Retaks

Save some money and get a Marlin and put a good Timney trigger in it.
timney makes a marlin trigger? since when?


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 03:31 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.