bucksnortinted

I would like to hear everyones opinion on these two,which one is just and all around better slug gun..........Ted

uncle matt

boy now you've went and asked a real question....

ReDoT

just because you said an "all around" gun i would say the 870 since its a repeater. H&R's are tack drivers in the slug world tho. but my 870WM with a hastings barrel is also very accurate out to 100 shooting buckhammers and hastings slugs

BigJ71

I guess it depends on what kind of hunting you do. If you stalk hunt the 870 is a better choice, if you still/stand hunt the H&R is better. All around I would go with the 870. I primarily hunt deer from a fixed/stand position soI hunt with an H&R Ultra Slug Hunter Deluxe 12ga....very accurate slug gun....very.

millerhunter13

i would say the H&R because i like single shots, if you are only using it for deer, go with the single if you might decide sometime to use it for birds or rabbits or somthing go with the 870

mideerslayer

I have both, and I prefer my H&R The 870 kicks like a raped mule, but it is good for deer drives (multiple shot's)

Im a fan of the one shot one kill method

younggun308

I thought that H&R 12ga.slug guns kick more than anything else.

USNRETHunter

Given the "all around" requirement, I'd have to say the 870. I both stand hunt by myself and group hunt. I love the H&R, but when a group is driving a herd past...multiple shots/multiple deer.

bucksnortinted

well so far I have an awesome bird gun,so I realy don't need the combo I know the 870 is a good gun but 99% of my hunting would be off a stand,and I could save alot of money going with the H&R also.........Ted

BOWHUNTERCOP

Ted, if you already have a great bird gun, then I agree go with the H&R....where are you located?