Fluted Barrel Question?
#4
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: S.W. Pa.-- Heart in North Central Pa. mountains-
Posts: 2,600
RE: Fluted Barrel Question?
Fluting increases the stiffness, just as ribs in a car's roof or plane variations in a hood. It also provides additional cooling surface.
#7
RE: Fluted Barrel Question?
I forget where but one of the better bbl manufacturers had a whole report on bbl fluting and it pretty much explained and showed how it's more cosmetic than anything.
Stiffness...ok, so why aren't really BIG bbls fluted (warship bbls for example) Surely they especially need stiffness.
Cooling: Theorymakes senceI guess but how many of us really shoot a bbl so darn fast that it gets hot enough so that a few flutes giving a fractional amount increase in surface area will be a big benifit? However, why then don't all the machine gun/automatic firearms have fluted bbls? Surely they especially would need extra surface for bbl cooling given the rate of fire they are capable of. When does one shoot so fast in a manual activated firearm that cooling becomes an issue?
I'm unconvinced fluting is anything other than cosmetic and that marketing simply make it a tactical, must-have, oh so important feature.
Actually what is fluitng anyways? it's longitudinal cuts in the bbls surface. Hmmm...rifling is just longitudinal cuts in the surface of the bbls bore. So...wouldn't rifling actually be specialized rifling?
Stiffness...ok, so why aren't really BIG bbls fluted (warship bbls for example) Surely they especially need stiffness.
Cooling: Theorymakes senceI guess but how many of us really shoot a bbl so darn fast that it gets hot enough so that a few flutes giving a fractional amount increase in surface area will be a big benifit? However, why then don't all the machine gun/automatic firearms have fluted bbls? Surely they especially would need extra surface for bbl cooling given the rate of fire they are capable of. When does one shoot so fast in a manual activated firearm that cooling becomes an issue?
I'm unconvinced fluting is anything other than cosmetic and that marketing simply make it a tactical, must-have, oh so important feature.
Actually what is fluitng anyways? it's longitudinal cuts in the bbls surface. Hmmm...rifling is just longitudinal cuts in the surface of the bbls bore. So...wouldn't rifling actually be specialized rifling?
#9
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Raleigh NC USA
Posts: 352
RE: Fluted Barrel Question?
According to one mfg, their fluted barrels have 180% of the surface area of a non-fluted model. That extra surface area helps dissipate the heat faster. Its sort of like the heat sinks stuck on CPUs, the kind with the big fins. If a solid block cooled the CPU faster that's what they would've used.
How much faster is heat dissipated? I've never seen any documentation of the difference, thoughyou can be certain that there is one. I'll have to poke around the net a bit out of curiosity.
Fluted barrels also have the advantage of reduced weight.
How much faster is heat dissipated? I've never seen any documentation of the difference, thoughyou can be certain that there is one. I'll have to poke around the net a bit out of curiosity.
Fluted barrels also have the advantage of reduced weight.
#10
RE: Fluted Barrel Question?
Weight? Not enough too justify.
Stiffness? Nope, regular barrels are stiffer.
Cooling? A little bit better than smooth.
Would I buy one? Yep, I like how they look. Thats what I would base my decision on, if you like it buy it, if not, then get a smooth barrel.
My 2 cents.
Stiffness? Nope, regular barrels are stiffer.
Cooling? A little bit better than smooth.
Would I buy one? Yep, I like how they look. Thats what I would base my decision on, if you like it buy it, if not, then get a smooth barrel.
My 2 cents.