40SW vs 45ACP
07-28-2006, 10:40 PM
#11
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: A flat lander lost in the mountains of Northern,AZ
Posts: 3,171
RE: 40SW vs 45ACP
ORIGINAL: JagMagMan
Man, if you need that one extra round, you are already in big trouble!
So, thats really a non-factor to me, but I'd still take the 45!
ORIGINAL: HighDesertWolf
Since both calibers have pretty much the same recoil Id go for the XD45 it has a higher magazine capacity too. the XD40 is 12+1 the XD45 is 13+1. I beleive a 45 has better incapacitating capabilities then the 40 which is a big plus if you ever had to use it in self defence and since the XD45 holds one more round over the XD40 I think the XD45 is deffinately the superior choice.
Since both calibers have pretty much the same recoil Id go for the XD45 it has a higher magazine capacity too. the XD40 is 12+1 the XD45 is 13+1. I beleive a 45 has better incapacitating capabilities then the 40 which is a big plus if you ever had to use it in self defence and since the XD45 holds one more round over the XD40 I think the XD45 is deffinately the superior choice.
So, thats really a non-factor to me, but I'd still take the 45!
very true LOL!!! but one more round hey why not never hurts to have more ammo then you need. just my thought
07-29-2006, 08:59 AM
#12
RE: 40SW vs 45ACP
Exactly.... That's why I have a Para Ordnance P13 (12 rounds +1 in the chamber). The P13 is a copy of the legendary Colt Commander style 1911. It's got a wide grip (double stack magazine) and with the 4 1/4" barrel, it is just right. Not too big to conceal, and not too small to be able to control easily.
Edit: Besides... This is a solid steel handgun. Steel frame, steel slide, steel barrel. Even though it's a 4 1/4" size "combat commander" style 1911, it is a heavy beast that packs a mighty punch! [8D]
Edit: Besides... This is a solid steel handgun. Steel frame, steel slide, steel barrel. Even though it's a 4 1/4" size "combat commander" style 1911, it is a heavy beast that packs a mighty punch! [8D]
07-29-2006, 10:40 AM
#13
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: A flat lander lost in the mountains of Northern,AZ
Posts: 3,171
RE: 40SW vs 45ACP
sharp lookin gun there, im just not a real big fan of para ordnance. I had some issues with LDA a couple years ago, left a bad taste in my mouth.
08-03-2006, 11:58 AM
#16
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Too close to Chicago
Posts: 3,337
RE: 40SW vs 45ACP
From Mike from Texas:
My buddy has a SIG 229 in 40 cal. and to me it feels like it recoils more than my XD45.
Pros and cons to both. Personal decision.
08-03-2006, 02:58 PM
#17
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Michigan
Posts: 3,329
RE: 40SW vs 45ACP
I like the 45 a lot but I find them difficult to conceal. This year I'll be getting a J-Frame in .38sp. Big guns are great but if you never carry because of the bulk what use is it.
Tom
Tom
08-05-2006, 09:40 PM
#18
Fork Horn
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Botetourt County, VA
Posts: 203
RE: 40SW vs 45ACP
Polymer framed handguns do a good job of sucking up the felt recoil. The .45 ACP will feel a bit stiffer because it is lauching a 230 gr. bullet and the .40 S&W is launching a 155 gr. bullet. Honestly, you cannot go wrong with either caliber and both cost about the same if you buy factory ammo. The key thing is too practice a lot and become proficient, familiar with the handgun you do choose. I have both calibers and feel confident with either one, should the need arise. Shot placement is the most important thing to stop the threat. I don't worry about magazine capacity because the handgun will only be used until I can get to my Rem. 870, which is close to where I sleep and loaded with 00 buckshot.
08-06-2006, 03:07 AM
#19
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: A flat lander lost in the mountains of Northern,AZ
Posts: 3,171
RE: 40SW vs 45ACP
ORIGINAL: MarinePride
Polymer framed handguns do a good job of sucking up the felt recoil. The .45 ACP will feel a bit stiffer because it is lauching a 230 gr. bullet and the .40 S&W is launching a 155 gr. bullet. Honestly, you cannot go wrong with either caliber and both cost about the same if you buy factory ammo. The key thing is too practice a lot and become proficient, familiar with the handgun you do choose. I have both calibers and feel confident with either one, should the need arise. Shot placement is the most important thing to stop the threat. I don't worry about magazine capacity because the handgun will only be used until I can get to my Rem. 870, which is close to where I sleep and loaded with 00 buckshot.
Polymer framed handguns do a good job of sucking up the felt recoil. The .45 ACP will feel a bit stiffer because it is lauching a 230 gr. bullet and the .40 S&W is launching a 155 gr. bullet. Honestly, you cannot go wrong with either caliber and both cost about the same if you buy factory ammo. The key thing is too practice a lot and become proficient, familiar with the handgun you do choose. I have both calibers and feel confident with either one, should the need arise. Shot placement is the most important thing to stop the threat. I don't worry about magazine capacity because the handgun will only be used until I can get to my Rem. 870, which is close to where I sleep and loaded with 00 buckshot.
08-06-2006, 03:11 AM
#20
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: A flat lander lost in the mountains of Northern,AZ
Posts: 3,171
RE: 40SW vs 45ACP
ORIGINAL: statjunk
I like the 45 a lot but I find them difficult to conceal. This year I'll be getting a J-Frame in .38sp. Big guns are great but if you never carry because of the bulk what use is it.
Tom
I like the 45 a lot but I find them difficult to conceal. This year I'll be getting a J-Frame in .38sp. Big guns are great but if you never carry because of the bulk what use is it.
Tom
