17 HMR uses?
07-24-2006, 02:43 PM
#1
Nontypical Buck
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Bradford, Ontario
Posts: 2,205
17 HMR uses?
For all those who are using a .17HMR can I ask what you are shooting/hunting with it? What kind of effective range does it have and whats its performance on varmints or small game? I am debating between that and a .222 or .223.
07-24-2006, 03:02 PM
#2
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Blissfield MI USA
Posts: 5,293
RE: 17 HMR uses?
Well it is really no match for any centerfire. It is used for about the same things you would use a .22 mag for. However it offers a slightly flatter trajectory and in most cases better accuracy if it isn't windy.
It shines on game woodchuck sized or smaller out to 150 yards, maybe 200 if your a good shot. Some shoot medium sized game as well, which is why they came out with the 20 grn XTP rounds.
As far performance, the v-max's are devastating on small game. If you want to eat it you better shoot it in the head. They lack penitration though on larger tougher game. I think this round was really designed as a medium range P Dog killer. The 20 grn XTPs are a heavier controled expansion bullet that penitrate better and carry more down range energy.
It is probably the most fun you will ever have with a rimfire, but I wouldn't compare it with a .222 or a .223. I mean you can shoot the same type of bullet but much heavier and at faster velocities. So your range and effectiveness on game (amount of damage they will do) is much higher.
Here is a great link if you are interested in the 17 HMR
Varmint Al's
Paul
It shines on game woodchuck sized or smaller out to 150 yards, maybe 200 if your a good shot. Some shoot medium sized game as well, which is why they came out with the 20 grn XTP rounds.
As far performance, the v-max's are devastating on small game. If you want to eat it you better shoot it in the head. They lack penitration though on larger tougher game. I think this round was really designed as a medium range P Dog killer. The 20 grn XTPs are a heavier controled expansion bullet that penitrate better and carry more down range energy.
It is probably the most fun you will ever have with a rimfire, but I wouldn't compare it with a .222 or a .223. I mean you can shoot the same type of bullet but much heavier and at faster velocities. So your range and effectiveness on game (amount of damage they will do) is much higher.
Here is a great link if you are interested in the 17 HMR
Varmint Al's
Paul
07-25-2006, 07:29 PM
#4
Banned
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: IOWA/25' UP
Posts: 7,145
RE: 17 HMR uses?
ORIGINAL: Paul L Mohr
Well it is really no match for any centerfire. It is used for about the same things you would use a .22 mag for. However it offers a slightly flatter trajectory and in most cases better accuracy if it isn't windy.
It shines on game woodchuck sized or smaller out to 150 yards, maybe 200 if your a good shot. Some shoot medium sized game as well, which is why they came out with the 20 grn XTP rounds.
As far performance, the v-max's are devastating on small game. If you want to eat it you better shoot it in the head. They lack penitration though on larger tougher game. I think this round was really designed as a medium range P Dog killer. The 20 grn XTPs are a heavier controled expansion bullet that penitrate better and carry more down range energy.
It is probably the most fun you will ever have with a rimfire, but I wouldn't compare it with a .222 or a .223. I mean you can shoot the same type of bullet but much heavier and at faster velocities. So your range and effectiveness on game (amount of damage they will do) is much higher.
Here is a great link if you are interested in the 17 HMR
Varmint Al's
Paul
Well it is really no match for any centerfire. It is used for about the same things you would use a .22 mag for. However it offers a slightly flatter trajectory and in most cases better accuracy if it isn't windy.
It shines on game woodchuck sized or smaller out to 150 yards, maybe 200 if your a good shot. Some shoot medium sized game as well, which is why they came out with the 20 grn XTP rounds.
As far performance, the v-max's are devastating on small game. If you want to eat it you better shoot it in the head. They lack penitration though on larger tougher game. I think this round was really designed as a medium range P Dog killer. The 20 grn XTPs are a heavier controled expansion bullet that penitrate better and carry more down range energy.
It is probably the most fun you will ever have with a rimfire, but I wouldn't compare it with a .222 or a .223. I mean you can shoot the same type of bullet but much heavier and at faster velocities. So your range and effectiveness on game (amount of damage they will do) is much higher.
Here is a great link if you are interested in the 17 HMR
Varmint Al's
Paul
HCH
07-25-2006, 07:59 PM
#5
Boone & Crockett
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Southwest Ohio
Posts: 10,277
RE: 17 HMR uses?
I use my .17 as a mixed bag gun in southern Illinois. In MY experience, it is a good squirrel gun, with relatively little damage even with body shots. I've also used it on crows, while squirrel hunting, at ranges from 60 to 240 yards. I agree with most folks that it isn't too good with coyotes, but, if they are number three or four on your priority list while hunting on any given day, it should do. At least, i would think that its preferable to using a 22-250 while squirrel hunting because you might see a coyote.
07-25-2006, 08:51 PM
#6
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: MB.
Posts: 2,984
RE: 17 HMR uses?
I had a 17 HMR and was a fun little gun to shoot but didn’t have to much success in accuracy. Didn’t shoot anything except for paper and coke cans. I also found it to be a pain to clean. I sold it and bought the 222. I wanted something that I could reload. Now it’s been a few month since I bought my .222 and I have it ready to sight in but just haven’t had the time. Hopefully I’ll have it sighted in later this summer. Looking forward to shooting this little guy...
07-31-2006, 07:28 PM
#8
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location:
Posts: 571
RE: 17 HMR uses?
I agree on all above with one exception, I have yet to see a .22 mag hold a group at 200 yds. the way a .17 HMR will, not even close! Shot a few groundhogs for fun with mine, head shots will drop them on the spot with out so much as a twitch!
08-01-2006, 03:10 PM
#9
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Blissfield MI USA
Posts: 5,293
RE: 17 HMR uses?
I don't see where anyone said the .22 mag was as accurate or more accurate? In most cases the 17 will be better, however on rimfirecentral there are a few guys that have .22 mags that are pretty darn accurate. I wouldn't call it the norm though.
Unless you have a deffective gun you can usually expect at least MOA accuracy out of a decent 17 HMR.
Paul
Unless you have a deffective gun you can usually expect at least MOA accuracy out of a decent 17 HMR.
Paul
