RE: My contest entrys OFFICAL P&Y score is in.........
 

Sorry if thats how you feel. You know there is a little green button next to my name. If you don't like what I have to say then please by all mean use it.

RE: My contest entrys OFFICAL P&Y score is in.........
 

I don't see anything wrong with being proud of a buck like that, what sucks is getting something your proud off shot down. I also don't see anything wrong with calling someone out on BS! Be proud! JMO:)

RE: My contest entrys OFFICAL P&Y score is in.........
 

You know what it appears your damned if you do and damned if you don't so you've posted your score let it go.

RE: My contest entrys OFFICAL P&Y score is in.........
 

I don't normally have a problem with what you have to say I am just tired of reliving this same old thread. Feel free to use your ignore button if you want but I personally don't deal with problems or confrontation by running away from them.

RE: My contest entrys OFFICAL P&Y score is in.........
 

Settle down boys, we're all buds here [8D]


Great buck regardless of score! Much bigger than anything I've laid eyes on this year[:'(]

RE: My contest entrys OFFICAL P&Y score is in.........
 

wow remind me never to bring anything up in here

RE: My contest entrys OFFICAL P&Y score is in.........
 

Teejay!

Don't worry about this ,this is an isolated incedent and most on this forum don't act like this . Buckeyehntr is really a great guy,and for you's new to the forum you will find that out as you post your question's on this forum.Buckeye has appoligized for his mistake and some on this forum don't want to let it go .So just ignore this and we can all get on with what we came here for . We all make mistake's we're only human .

nubo

RE: My contest entrys OFFICAL P&Y score is in.........
 

Buckeye,

I didn't realize that you had all of the PMs asking you to post the official scores when they came in. My apologies!

RE: My contest entrys OFFICAL P&Y score is in.........
 

Yep, it's a nice buck but this is exactly how most folks have viewed it. To be sure, telling someone you shot a "160 class" buck usually brings up an image of a MUCH different class of animal??? I think most folks are simply interested in frame size and don't care much about the extra trash. It's a good solid animal but MOST do not use SCI scores. Congrats on a fine buck and I hope you get another next season!

RE: My contest entrys OFFICAL P&Y score is in.........
 

Come on guys, lets all take a deep breath and a step back from the computer.

Buckeye shot a great deer, and I never questioned the score. There is a huge differance in size between a gross 160" deer and a net 160" deer! I have seen deer that have scored in the 186" range that looked like a 140" tops, and I have seen deer that looked like 120" deer that scored in the 140"s. Antlers can be very decieving, and the only sure thing is that they aren't worth argueing about.

Buckeye is making a big deal about this, but others made a big deal about him posting his score in the contest! He is trying to back up what he said and I respect that. He was called out as a liar and proved that he wasn't. Could he have handled it better? Sure! But when you work so hard and put in so much time to achieve what he did, you better believe you are going to get emotional about someone questioning it.

Lets face it guys, it is one hell of a nice deer that anybody would be proud of, but yet it isn't worth fighting over. I look at all of you guys as my friends even thought I don't know many of you! Something like this isn't worth and arguement or looseing a friend, even if you have never met them in person.

Its the offseason, tempers flare this time of year, so lets all take a step back and go shed hunting, scouting, or shoot our bows. ;)