RE: legalizing crossbows
 

Wasnt stereotyping , my comments were directed to you

RE: legalizing crossbows
 

There was just som1 killed with a compound bow, it had an automatic lock when drawn & the guy pointed it at his buddy in the car ....went off & killed him

RE: legalizing crossbows
 

You want to use a crossbow no biggie.
But don't force me to......
Don't cut in to my season to make room for yours.
Cross bow & bow almost the same both could be used in the same season.
The only thing I have about cross bows learn there range just because you can hit the target at 35yds doesn't mean you have CE enough to kill cleanly.

RE: legalizing crossbows
 

No Arthur, they are thought provoking when they open my mind to a new way of seeing things. Which, initially you did! When you start telling me and the board that compounds, crossbows, and any advancement since the Indian days are boring and easy and no challenge, thus no accomplishment or sense of enjoyment, you lost my admiration for your viewpoint.
I had thought you were sharing some insight on your opinion and I can respect that. Heck everyone can appreciate and respect another guys opinion, at least until you slam most everything that this particular forum is about. Then it's time to m reconsider your viewpoint from being thought provoking to being anti-everything except what you want. At that point it's not an opinion, it's dictatorship, and that's when i quit listening.

RE: legalizing crossbows
 

A lot of compound hunters would drop their bows and go rifle if there was one big season - so that is a moot point Arthur P

You shoot a variety of bows like I have - good ! You then know exactly how much more accurate a modern compound is. Go to any 3D shoot that allows crossbows and you'll see a consitancy. Compounder have the best scores, folllowed by crossbows, then the recurve/longbows with sights etc than the more primitive categories etc etc.

I long ago realized you cannot regulte a slob going out, buying a weapon and going hunting. Can't do it be it a compound or a longbow or a rifle or a crossbow. in fact, if that is being taken into consideration, you'd WANT easier weapons that allow the shooter to become better faster, wouldn't you ?

RE: legalizing crossbows
 

So, weren't you stereotyping my 'recurve buddies' by that comment, slugman? Of course you were.

Same kind of thing happened just last year with a crossbow and it's own automatic lock. A man set his kid up in a treestand with a crossbow. At the end of the hunt, the kid was lowering the LOADED crossbow down on a rope, the trigger got caught on something. The crossbow went off, killing the kid.

With proper training and basic safety practices, neither of those people would have died. Take the automatic locks off and, again, neither of them would have died. Difference is, without the locks, they would not have been messing around with loaded weapons, so those accidents could not have happened.

RE: legalizing crossbows
 

What you say is true enough, GMPT. But I do not consider it a moot point.

Yes, that's why I think they should use compounds instead of crossbows.

RE: legalizing crossbows
 

A tragedy , but the parents fault for not teaching his son how to correctly use.

I am unable to use a bow due to a car accident , so per you I should not have an alternative ?

RE: legalizing crossbows
 

I've already answered that question, slugman, a couple pages back.

RE: legalizing crossbows
 

And you even offered a brand to look at on my other thread. Thanks