Monster buck challenge!!!
 

Just wondering your opinions. I noticed the potential record buck for Missouri and state record buck shot in Oklahoma last year are similar. The Oklahoma buck has more non typical points on it than the Missouri deer has. The challenge is, if both deer walked out at the same time and presented a shot, which one would you take?

Missouri deer



or Oklahoma deer

RE: Monster buck challenge!!!
 

i would take the buck in the second pic........has alot of curvy points and a big rack to......

RE: Monster buck challenge!!!
 

I would have too shoot the Missouri Buck. Good luck and Aim True.

RE: Monster buck challenge!!!
 

Oklahoma buck, probably cause im from oklahoma;) Actually, i like the funky lookin racks like the OK deer. Plus, i know the guy who shot that deer, he comes into the pro shop every now and then, matter of fact i think i worked on that bow last year, i dont remember though.

RE: Monster buck challenge!!!
 

...Hmmm, you really know how to hurt a guy don't you!

Man if these two bucks walked out at the same time, each giving the same high percentage shot I would probably have a brain hemorrhage trying to figure out which one I wanted. You have to remember, I have never seen a buck that I didn't like!....

But I could do this, yes indeed I can make a choice if I have to...No problem, let's see, I really like the clean lines of the Missouri buck...but I do love those stickers on the OK buck....Wow, check out the body on that Missouri monster, I just love that....Oh my, look at the color and texture of the cape on that Oklahoma brute, that is awesome, I really like that....

...What do you mean they just walked out of my shooting lane??? [:o]

RE: Monster buck challenge!!!
 

If they were both in the same area..I'd let them walk and look for their Daddy!

RE: Monster buck challenge!!!
 

Who's being picky?

I guess if I had to choose I'd shoot the MO deer first. I just have a thing for big typicals.

RE: Monster buck challenge!!!
 

I would take them both wouldn't you??? Just wait for them to line up and zip an arrow through both of them or since most of us have extreemely quiet bows we would be able to get two shots off right. Heck when the first bruiser runs off the other would just think he intimidated him and stand there.

In all honesty I would take the Missouri buck. He just looks down right huge from rack to rear and MEAN!!!!

RE: Monster buck challenge!!!
 

i second the shoot um both i have 2 buck tags to use and boy that would sure make the rest of the season easy !!!:D:D:D[:-] but seriously i would take either one and be extremely happy. the first one to present the best shot !!

RE: Monster buck challenge!!!
 

I would shoot at, and miss the Missouri buck. Then I'd beat my bow against a tree and go home to cry.

RE: Monster buck challenge!!!
 

missouri deer

RE: Monster buck challenge!!!
 

Does this assume I only have 1 antlered tag?:D

RE: Monster buck challenge!!!
 

Even though I'm from Oklahoma, I think I'd take the Missouri buck. I just like the looks of a monster typical. And like was mentioned before, just look at his face, and the size of the body!!

RE: Monster buck challenge!!!
 

I would take which ever one gave me the best shot?:D First come first served!!:D and go home happy!!;)

RE: Monster buck challenge!!!
 

Definately the MO buck for me as well. That's assuming they both came out simultaneously because if one was before the other I'd sent an arrow through the first one and might not know the second existed....that's after a warm trickle fell down my pant leg.

RE: Monster buck challenge!!!
 

The MO buck for me, he dwarfs the OK buck IMO.

RE: Monster buck challenge!!!
 

Missouri buck hands down...

RE: Monster buck challenge!!!
 

I take a crack at the missouri buck...if he didn't smell the crap i left in my pants first..lol....man that buck is BAD TO THE BONE!!!

RE: Monster buck challenge!!!
 

The Missouri buck. Why, because I'm from Missouri. Oh man, just thinkin there walkin around out there gives me a fuzzy feeling all over. I'll take one 1/2 that size and be super happy.

RE: Monster buck challenge!!!
 

If I saw both those bucks walk into me,First I would crap myself,then i would have to pick up my jaw,Thank the good lord for this oppertunity,and shoot the missouri buck.But if you could get them side by side and take both.I'd quit hunting after that

RE: Monster buck challenge!!!
 

I am not being biased or anything b/c I am from OKlahoma, b/c I really don't know which I would take myself, but The OK deer scored 223" B&C with 29 scoreable points and the MO deer was green scored at around 195" B&C. It sure would be hard to pass that mean looking old MO deer, he is probably the meanest looking deer I have seen. But I sure do like all the trash on the OK buck. I really don't know myself, I am torn between the two.