Same buck,or same gene pool
 

Night time shot is from the other day.Daytime picture is from last season.I'm still trying to determine if it is the same deer,or just from the same gene pool.If it is the same buck,it looks like it may have lost some size this year.There are enough similarities in the racks to really make me wonder if it is the same deer or not.

I think they are same gene pull but different buck.

it must be nice to have deer like that right in your back yard nice pics

Yeah, your property and house look awesome. Looking to sell?

Looks very similar. Looks like his g2 and g3s have grown but lost some on his brows. Stick him with a arrow!

Im gonna say same genes

same genes, definitely a different buck though.

yea definaitly different deer. The one from last year looks like her is a few years older. Both good deer and I love tha you can see your house in the background! must be nice to have a 50 yard walk to the stand!

Different Bucks for sure but as has been said it looks like from the same gene pool. Nice Bucks,great house,nice situation.

Definitely not the same bucks, but they do look similar enough to be from the same gene pool.

Yea, there's no way he got younger - same pool.

Shoot them all and put them together for a family Photo! LOL, Just kidding, in Lacrosse I was doing some work for a guy, and saw a monster in his back yard. No less than 16 point and tall and wide! It took my breath away, and the guy offered me to shoot it withmy bow. I did think about it, but had to decline. That deer probably has 20 names from 20 differant people down the block. Bird feeder bucks wouldnt taste any differant to me, but too many broken hearts down the way.

Looks like the same deer but the day time looks taller... Same exact brow tines

Thats not my house.That house is actually the neighbors next to the place I hunt.This spot boarders a nature preserve where there is no hunting.

same genes. i like the crooked bt

Definitely not the same bucks, but it would be nice if they was both still around cuz the day pic but will def be alot better

Brothers mabey?

I think same gene's, but two different deer.
When was the second picture taken ?

X2 and a nice gene pool it is!

They look to be different bucks but probably the same father.

Rutt, you live in Northern Illinois? Looks like a style of house around me.

No,I live in CT.Good deer hunting,but it is unfortunatley the land of the liberals.

Come to Illinois and see what goes on here with our political system!

I have a couple urban spots that look close to that. I worry a little about trespasers but its within a 30 min drive of where I live in downtown Chicago so I can't complain. We also have a few decent bucks since no one really hunts my area.

Hard to tell off one pic of each...night time photos change the look a little....it does look like the same genes if not the same buck. look at the spot on his nose it almost looks like its there on the night photo...Just my opinion..

Looks
 

Looks like the same buck to me. Curves in his brow tines are too similar.

Different bucks.