brodyb51

Not the same. Look at where the brow tines start on the main beams. The top buck has maybe 1" from the base of the antlers to where the brows start where as the bottom buck has much more. Looks like 2+" on the bottom buck.

WNYhunter

also look at the tips. the first ones right side looks like it curves up and they look closer together. I think they are different. good for you though

AR Bowhunter

Nope, look at the shape of the browtines real close.

125py

for sure the same....no doubt

Average Joe

Doesn't look quite the same to me. Maybe they are siblings? Aside from some small differences in their antlers such as inside spread differences and brow tines looking different, the buck in the top pic. doesn't have nearly as large of a white throat patch as the lower pic. JMO

BigDaddy12t

Ok, I was convinced that they were the same buck, but now that you pointed out the throat patch difference, I am leaning th e other way.

TeamWiscoUNIT61

darn, thought i would be the first to mention it. Throat patch/brow tines are enough to tell me its a different buck. Very similar but, i've seen 'twin' bucks before so...easily could be different

TeamWiscoUNIT61

also compare the right main beams...not the same

sea_bee77

different deer notice the one on the bottom has the white chest patch and the one on the top doesn't. also the buck at the tops g3 is bigger than his g2 and the one on the bottoms g2 is bigger than his g3.

BigBuck95

I think it is...look at the little bend near the top of the left brow tine. It would be very coincidental that two almost identicle deer would have that same weird antler curve.

BigBuck95