I don't think its the same deer. The left G2 in the 1st pic appears to curve inwards, in the 2nd pic it appears to curve up. Also, look at the angle of the main beams as they extend out from the head, in the 1st pic its a lower more horizontal angle, in the 2nd its a more vertical angle. But I'll be damned if they aren't brothers/twins

Look at the end of the right antler on the top buck, it is bent upwards at almost a 45 degree angle. The right antler on the bottom buck isn't nearly as angled.

Also, the top deer has a left browtine taller than the right one. On the bottom deer its vice versa.

for sure not the same buck, this was exactly what i was going to point out. nice bucks though!

For sure, for sure not the same deer. Look at the right G3 of each deer.

in the first pic the deer has his head down more covering the throatpatch..thats why they appear different...same deer

No way, buck 1 wider and beams goes out, has a noticeable side to side difference, the r g-3 turns in.
Buck 2 is symmetrical with no noticeable side to side difference, r g-3 turns out, beams go up.

well...i looked through about 500 pics....and from the flash it leaves white spots on the deer sometimes...so the throat patch might not be a throat patch after all..how bout another pic?
i am on the fence..twins or just the same deer...
rack: spread looks the same, the pics are takin at different distances and different angles..so it aint apples to apples imo
i can see the brow tine suggestions, but it could go both ways when ya add distanceXangle in there
need another set of pics lol

Sorry guys, those are the only 2 pics I have of those deer. I am really thinking different bucks.